Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Doug Schaefer
Yes, that generally how we work too. We're big users of Gerrit internally here on Momentics. That's generally how things go. Discussions happen in our bug system (JIRA), but only comments on the code happen in Gerrit. In all the bugzilla's I've looked at over the years, there actually weren't t

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Doug Schaefer
No they're not. I can't see any way that patches in bugzilla are easier than gerrit. It's one "Push to Gerrit" and one "Publish and Submit" clicks away from getting a contribution made and accepted. And can't help wonder that these two statements aren't related in some way: "m2e has no plans to a

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Mickael Istria
On 10/04/2013 09:00 PM, Ian Bull wrote: I'm not sure how the more experienced Gerrit users deal with this. I don't consider myself as an expert, but I generally try to keep discussion related to use-case, test scenario and possible designs on the Bugzilla, and put discussions about code itself

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Ed Willink
Hi This seems backwatds. To my way of thinking Gerrit should be making GIT and Bugzilla better. If it tries to replace them it is sure to leave a lot of users disappointed and irritated. Therefore once the Gerrit ping-pong is complete, the Gerrit results should be transferred in their entir

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Shawn Pearce
On Fri, Oct 4, 2013 at 12:00 PM, Ian Bull wrote: > I really like the flow that Gerrit provides. Pushing commits is easier than > creating patchs and uploading them. However, I find with Gerrit (or our use > of Gerrit) is that the discussion is now spread across multiple mediums. > Bugs / feature r

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Jesse McConnell
hm, I should probably point out I pretty strictly using the command line for all git interactions...just don't trust that eclipse plugin magic :P -- jesse mcconnell jesse.mcconn...@gmail.com On Fri, Oct 4, 2013 at 1:59 PM, Jesse McConnell wrote: > personally, I love the _idea_ of gerrit, but wh

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Jesse McConnell
personally, I love the _idea_ of gerrit, but when it comes to processing a patch I prefer a more hands on process of reading the patching, applying the patch, reviewing the patch inline and then committing any tweaks, then pushing it jesse -- jesse mcconnell jesse.mcconn...@gmail.com On Fri, Oc

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Ian Bull
I really like the flow that Gerrit provides. Pushing commits is easier than creating patchs and uploading them. However, I find with Gerrit (or our use of Gerrit) is that the discussion is now spread across multiple mediums. Bugs / feature requests come in on bugzilla where some discussion happens.

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Igor Fedorenko
To use gerrit you still have to have bugzilla account, know git but additionally need to learn gerrit concepts and UI. Once you learn gerrit, it is about as difficult to use as attaching patches to bugzilla... although after not using gerrit for a few weeks I always have to google exact push synta

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Pascal Rapicault
Though we enabled gerrit for p2, I must admit that I like patches on bugzilla easier. For the sake of understanding, could you please detail what do you harder with gerrit? -Original Message- From: cross-project-issues-dev-boun...@eclipse.org [mailto:cross-project-issues-dev-boun...@ec

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Jesse McConnell
jetty generally finds this to be the case as well -- jesse mcconnell jesse.mcconn...@gmail.com On Fri, Oct 4, 2013 at 12:54 PM, Igor Fedorenko wrote: > Yes. Patches attached to bugzilla are easier. > > -- > Regards, > Igor > > > On 2013-10-04 12:25 PM, Mickael Istria wrote: > >> On 10/04/2013

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Igor Fedorenko
Yes. Patches attached to bugzilla are easier. -- Regards, Igor On 2013-10-04 12:25 PM, Mickael Istria wrote: On 10/04/2013 06:08 PM, Igor Fedorenko wrote: m2e has no plans to accept gerrit contributions, at least not for now. I'm curious: Why is this so? Did you find a process that makes cont

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Igor Fedorenko
git-format-patch formatted patches attached to bugzilla is the only way to contribute to m2e and I generally review contributions for the next milestone build. So my statement was strictly related to accepting contributions through gerrit or any other means except bugzilla for that matter. I simp

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Luna M2 repo and packages are ready

2013-10-04 Thread David M Williams
We just call these "milestones" ... the term "release" we reserve for ... well, releases. :) And, no, we do not currently tag milestones b3aggrcon files ... the reason being is there is a lot of flexibility (i.e. looseness) in how people have set them up, so you may or may not get the same re

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Wayne Beaton
In my defense, the push to Git had two major motivators: 1) CVS is no longer supported and has--as I understand it--several major open bugs that aren't being addressed 2) With the introduction of Git, something had to go; Webmaster does not have infinite resources.

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Mickael Istria
On 10/04/2013 06:08 PM, Igor Fedorenko wrote: m2e has no plans to accept gerrit contributions, at least not for now. I'm curious: Why is this so? Did you find a process that makes contributing easier than it is by Gerrit? -- Mickael Istria Eclipse developer at JBoss, by Red Hat

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Ed Merks
Igor, I think folks generally should have a choice about using gerrit, but I'm wondering if you're statement below is stronger. I.e., do you mean "m2e has no plans to accept contributions"? If the project intends to accept contributions and the source is maintained in a git repo, I'm not

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Henrik Rentz-Reichert
the eTrice project is already running a HIPP with Gerrit trigger. It's just great! It significantly reduced the time I spend with reviews -Henrik Am 04.10.2013 16:22, schrieb Doug Schaefer: > I almost wonder if we should just enable Gerrit for all projects. That's what > we do internally here fo

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Igor Fedorenko
m2e has no plans to accept gerrit contributions, at least not for now. Having gerring enabled for m2e will be confusing. -- Regards, Igor On 2013-10-04 10:22 AM, Doug Schaefer wrote: I almost wonder if we should just enable Gerrit for all projects. That's what we do internally here for all git

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Luna M2 repo and packages are ready

2013-10-04 Thread Mickael Istria
Hi, Thanks for the release. Is there a tag on simrel repo available for this release? -- Mickael Istria Eclipse developer at JBoss, by Red Hat My blog - My Tweets

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Mickael Istria
On 10/04/2013 04:22 PM, Doug Schaefer wrote: I almost wonder if we should just enable Gerrit for all projects. That's what we do internally here for all git repos that feed into product. It's great for all the reasons you mention Ed. I can already imagine the various posts from Wayne on blogs/T

Re: [cross-project-issues-dev] Making your project more openŠhowto enable Gerrit

2013-10-04 Thread Doug Schaefer
I almost wonder if we should just enable Gerrit for all projects. That's what we do internally here for all git repos that feed into product. It's great for all the reasons you mention Ed. The thing I like most about it is the verification jobs in co-ordination with Hudson. You have so much mor

[cross-project-issues-dev] Luna M2 repo and packages are ready

2013-10-04 Thread David M Williams
Congratulations and thanks to all participating projects! repo (built-in): http://download.eclipse.org/releases/luna/ packages: http://www.eclipse.org/downloads/index-developer.php And thanks in advance for early testing for Luna Release ___ cross-pr