Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-05 Thread Greg A. Woods
At Mon, 5 Apr 2021 07:04:32 - (UTC), mlel...@serpens.de (Michael van Elst) wrote: Subject: Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt? > > Someone would need to write code to "upgrade" vnodes. I doubt that's > trivial.

Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-05 Thread Manuel Bouyer
On Sun, Apr 04, 2021 at 03:13:35PM -0700, Greg A. Woods wrote: > I would think it's not just CDs and hypervisor-provided virtual devices > that can have multiple partitions, use wedges, and yet be read-only. > > Are not a wide variety of removable storage devices also capable of > being made "read

Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-05 Thread Michael van Elst
wo...@planix.ca ("Greg A. Woods") writes: >Given the layers of devices and code involved, perhaps it might be >possible to just honour the original mode requested by the code opening >the first partition to mount a filesystem, and then to upgrade the vnode >to write mode if/when that mount is upgr

Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-04 Thread Greg A. Woods
At Sun, 4 Apr 2021 01:19:44 -0700, John Nemeth wrote: Subject: Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt? > > Given that it is possible to have partitions on CDs, which is > common on Suns, but not so much elsewhere, and that anywhere the

Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-04 Thread John Nemeth
On Apr 4, 7:34, Michael van Elst wrote: } wo...@planix.ca ("Greg A. Woods") writes: } } >So with Xen one can export a "disk" (disk, file, LVM partiion, etc.) } >with "access=ro", and that is enforced. } } >However if one tries to mount such a disk in a domU as root, it fails. } } > root on

Re: how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-04 Thread Michael van Elst
wo...@planix.ca ("Greg A. Woods") writes: >So with Xen one can export a "disk" (disk, file, LVM partiion, etc.) >with "access=ro", and that is enforced. >However if one tries to mount such a disk in a domU as root, it fails. > root on dk1 > vfs_mountroot: can't open root device, erro

how do I mount a read-only filesystem from the "root device" prompt?

2021-04-03 Thread Greg A. Woods
So with Xen one can export a "disk" (disk, file, LVM partiion, etc.) with "access=ro", and that is enforced. However if one tries to mount such a disk in a domU as root, it fails. When one first looks at the code which does the initial vfs_mountroot it would appear to be correct -- i.e. it is try