Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US? (Re: to outlaw general purpose computers)

2002-07-03 Thread R. A. Hettinga
At 7:31 PM -0500 on 7/2/02, Harmon Seaver wrote: Wasn't the dollar backed by silver for quite awhile? There were definitely real silver dollars coined for quite awhile, and the dollar said something on it about silver certificate. Likewise many smaller coins had a high silver content --

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread jamesd
-- On 3 Jul 2002 at 2:36, Anonymous wrote: However doing a straight devaluation was politically unacceptable at the time. Because the dollar was pegged to gold, devaluing the dollar meant in effect increasing the value of gold in terms of dollars. This would represent a tremendous

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread Marcel Popescu
From: Anonymous [EMAIL PROTECTED] Even libertarian monetarists such as Milton Friedman agree that this is the proper approach when dealing with a depression. Murray Rothbard's law number 17: all economists specialize in the field they suck most. Friedman is good in many areas, but he sucks

[OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread James A. Donald
-- On 3 Jul 2002 at 2:36, Anonymous wrote: At the time, the U.S. faced a significant chance of a Communist/Socialist revolution such as had been seen in several other countries. Class warfare was widespread, The high point of support for socialism among the masses in the US was the

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread Patrick Chkoreff
Roosevelt needed to in effect devalue the dollar during the Great Depression. However doing a straight devaluation was politically unacceptable at the time. Because the dollar was pegged to gold, devaluing the dollar meant in effect increasing the value of gold in terms of

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread Michael Motyka
Anonymous [EMAIL PROTECTED] Just curious, but what was the rationale under which private posession of gold was made illegal in the US? It boggles the mind... snip However doing a straight devaluation was politically unacceptable at the time. Because the dollar was pegged to gold,

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-03 Thread Tim May
On Wednesday, July 3, 2002, at 08:50 AM, Michael Motyka wrote: IIRC many of the wealthy were quick enough to ship huge amounts of gold to Europe. That is one reason I have heard given that the St Gauden's $20 gold pices of that era are possibly poor investments - there is a reservoir of them

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US? (Re: to outlaw general purpose computers)

2002-07-03 Thread Harmon Seaver
On Tue, Jul 02, 2002 at 11:34:17PM -0400, R. A. Hettinga wrote: At 7:31 PM -0500 on 7/2/02, Harmon Seaver wrote: Wasn't the dollar backed by silver for quite awhile? There were definitely real silver dollars coined for quite awhile, and the dollar said something on it about silver

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US? (Re: to outlaw general purpose computers)

2002-07-02 Thread Harmon Seaver
Wasn't the dollar backed by silver for quite awhile? There were definitely real silver dollars coined for quite awhile, and the dollar said something on it about silver certificate. Likewise many smaller coins had a high silver content -- this ended sometime during Vietnam, not sure the year.

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US?

2002-07-02 Thread Anonymous
Just curious, but what was the rationale under which private posession of gold was made illegal in the US? It boggles the mind... Roosevelt needed to in effect devalue the dollar during the Great Depression. In a deflationary depression, this acts as an inflationary force to cancel the

Re: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US? (Re: to outlaw general purpose computers)

2002-07-02 Thread Duncan Frissell
On Tue, 2 Jul 2002, Adam Back wrote: Just curious, but what was the rationale under which private possession of gold was made illegal in the US? It boggles the mind... Adam Eric's comment are correct. A bit more info. The US wanted to devalue the $ and substitute a general gold standard

RE: [OT] why was private gold ownership made illegal in the US? (Re: to outlaw general purpose computers)

2002-07-02 Thread Blanc
Duncan Frissell said: By forcing Americans to turn in their gold before devaluation, the Feds got more gold for less money. But: the individual common folk couldn't be forced to turn in their gold if the govmt didn't know they had any, right, since gold wasn't/isn't