[db-wg] chair selection

2023-04-13 Thread denis walker via db-wg
Colleagues The process for selecting chairs and terms of office is documented here https://www.ripe.net/participate/ripe/wg/active-wg/db/database-wg-chair-selection-process Accordingly, Denis's term of office expires at RIPE 86. If anyone is interested in joining the team please contact db-wg-cha

[db-wg] Fwd: Geofeed purpose

2023-04-13 Thread denis walker via db-wg
Colleagues A question for the legal team at the RIPE NCC. Would a simple purpose, as suggested below, address all the concerns you had about the use of the "geofeed:" attribute and allow you to remove any restrictions you felt were necessary when it was introduced? cheers denis co-chair DB-WG -

[db-wg] Fwd: Geofeed purpose

2023-04-13 Thread Sylvain BAYA via db-wg
Dear RIPE DB-WG, Hope this email finds you in good health! Please find my comment below, inline... Thanks. Le 13/04/2023 à 11:29, denis walker via db-wg a écrit : Colleagues A question for the legal team at the RIPE NCC. Would a simple purpose, as suggested below, address all the concerns you

Re: [db-wg] Geofeed purpose

2023-04-13 Thread Randy Bush via db-wg
IANAL and try not to play one on the net. but ... my reading of why NCC legal has problems with the geofeed: attribute is that they see the NCC as legally liable for the content of the geofeed data file to which it points. this concern may be based, for example, in the courts finding pirate bay

Re: [db-wg] Geofeed purpose

2023-04-13 Thread denis walker via db-wg
Hi Randy, Sylvain IANAL either but I understood the main legal issue was that there is no defined purpose to use the RIPE Database for geolocation services. So whatever is in that referenced file is not covered by a valid purpose. We have had the "geoloc:" attribute for a long time. The value of t