Bug#927987: Don't tell users to use ext3

2019-04-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
Maybe the document should say "don't worry, the installer process will walk you through this. /tmp: well I just use tmpfs. Also the worst thing is if one searches on Google for /var /home vs. just / Debian articles, he will find ../jessie/.. and has to put in the word ../stretch/.. in the URL to

Bug#927045: ^C doesn't work when booting into recovery mode

2019-04-13 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: installation-reports Severity: minor Just want to let you know after a fresh install, when booting into "(recovery mode)" from the grub menu, and typing the root passwd, # cat ^C doesn't interrupt cat, etc. One needs ^Z, then "kill %" to stop it. Yes, these just reported the same as on

Bug#927037: Message didn't fully fit inside its window

2019-04-13 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor I recall when the graphical installer got to this message, Name: partman-crypto/progress/plain_erase_text Type: text Description: The installer is now overwriting ${DEVICE} with zeroes to delete its previous contents. This step may be skipped by

Bug#849509: Logs show popularity-contest installation indeed occurs after user says no

2019-04-02 Thread Dan Jacobson
OK. The package is actually installed. It is just the message about that being buffered until the next interaction probably.

Bug#926149: AMD: Add nomodeset kernel parameter to avoid black screen

2019-04-02 Thread Dan Jacobson
All I know is I researched what ISO I could put on a USB stick and take to my mountain for a minimal install with no network. It worked fine, after I added that nomodeset line. It is a shame if officially debian no longer can be installed without a network.

Bug#849509: Logs show popularity-contest installation indeed occurs after user says no

2019-04-02 Thread Dan Jacobson
Actually try this: When you get to the popularity-contest question, wait a few moments, then answer "no". Later examine the logs. You will see actual installation (and then removal) indeed occurs *after* the user has answered "no". So the user's eyes didn't fool him after all.

Bug#926149: AMD: Add nomodeset kernel parameter to avoid black screen

2019-04-02 Thread Dan Jacobson
I'll be very happy to help you test this week. Next week I wish to proceed with final installation though. BH> Was the firmware (firmware-amd-graphics package) installed on your test BH> system? https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=925556#25 mentions what ISO I used, and all logs

Bug#925556: use UUIDs 100% in grub, not /dev/sdX

2019-04-01 Thread Dan Jacobson
retitle 925556 Use UUID, not sdX on grub linux lines thanks The problem simply turns out to be: grub lines like linux /boot/vmlinuz-4.9.0-8-amd64 root=/dev/sdb2 ro quiet are simply bound to fail: When the computer boots, no matter when for the installer, or later, the

Bug#926149: AMD: Add nomodeset kernel parameter to avoid black screen

2019-04-01 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: installation-reports With the latest AMD CPUs the kernel will attempt to use the AMDGPU kernel driver. Alas this will result in a black screen on the minimal system installed by the installer. Therefore on all three of these lines in /boot/grub/grub.cfg linux /boot/vmlinuz-...

Bug#849509: Can't blame the user for trying to read the messages

2019-03-31 Thread Dan Jacobson
I suppose in the logs, of Mar 27 23:38:24 in-target: Preparing to unpack .../popularity-contest_1.64_all.deb ... Mar 27 23:38:24 in-target: Unpacking popularity-contest (1.64) ... Mar 27 23:38:24 in-target: Setting up popularity-contest (1.64) ... Mar 27 23:38:24 in-target: Removing

Bug#925556: UEFI or not, can't mount /dev

2019-03-29 Thread Dan Jacobson
Trying again with expert install and some different choices, and putting nomodeset in the grub finally booted it. I'll send new logs soon.

Bug#925991: Show version on splash screen

2019-03-29 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor The Installer splash screen should show the version number.

Bug#925887: Users fooled by Busybox boilerplate

2019-03-28 Thread Dan Jacobson
Maybe just have a message: "press TAB to see all available commands." That would show both built-ins and non builtins. (Hope TAB works.)

Bug#925897: Always also offer UTC when asking timezone

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor Let's say you are asking the user what time zone he is in for some country: Eastern Time Zone Plains Time Zone Mountain Time Zone Other Well I recall in expert mode installation, UTC is also always present: Eastern Time Zone Plains Time Zone Mountain

Bug#925896: tasksel_first: Give examples of "Standard system utilities" when asking

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor In tasksel_first_0.png the user is totally helpless trying to figure out what you mean by "Standard system utilities" So give some examples. Say "Standard system utilities (cat, ls...)" or "Standard system utilities (gnome, kde...)" or something,

Bug#925895: partman_choose_partition: mention that there will be one more screen with a list of proposed changes

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: wishlist Here on partman_choose_partition_0.png we see both things that are about to be changed, and things that will stay the same, but we can't tell which are which. So right after the words "write changes to disk" you need to add "(You will be first shown a

Bug#925893: Also ask "Do not configure the network at this time" *before* trying to configure the network

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor Please also ask "Do not configure the network at this time" *before* trying to configure the network. Not only after, and failing. That way users installing offline wouldn't need to answer several futile questions and have futile DHCP packets sent to

Bug#925892: Add version name next to number

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Users often hear "Stretch", "Buster", but on the installer, they see just "Debian 9". Therefore please make it say "Debian 9 (Stretch)" or "Debian 9 Stretch". In fact much wiser would be to do what iOS does, and keep them a top secret.

Bug#925891: Debian Black Screen of Death worse than Microsoft's Blue Screen of Death

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: wishlist In bug #925556, I showed you what a failed install looks like to a user who has booted via grub's "(recovery mode)" entries. If the user hadn't touched the keyboard, a normal boot would instead proceed, whereupon the user would just end up on a black

Bug#925889: Add "exit" or "Reboot" to the menus

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: wishlist The menus are great, But you forgot one item. "Reboot". You see, no matter how the user scours the menus, he cannot find the proper way to exit (reboot). "Well he is supposed to know how to do that himself!" Yes, but he wants the "proper" way to

Bug#925888: Add Quick rescue mode

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Today let's discuss Rescue Mode. I think you should offer a second rescue mode choice. Call it "Quick Rescue Mode". List it right after Rescue Mode. Quick Rescue Mode would drop the user into a shell right away. No questions about languages. Yup, unfair. Sorry. No

Bug#925886: Rescue mode: When asking device to use as root file system, give more detailed choices

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Severity: minor Here there is a high chance the user will chose the wrong item, because he does not recall which of his disks are which. Therefore you need to present more details, which yes, can fit on the same line. Add sizes and partition types and disk label stuff

Bug#925556: UEFI or not, can't mount /dev

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
logs.gz Description: application/gzip

Bug#925556: UEFI or not, can't mount /dev

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
I tried installing again. (This time with no network.) The normal graphical install. All goes fine, but in the logs there is one "Failed to get": $ grep -A 2 'Failed to get' syslog |cut -c 17- base-installer: warning: Failed to get debconf answer 'base-installer/kernel/linux/initrd'.

Bug#925556: UEFI or not, can't mount /dev

2019-03-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
> "SM" == Steve McIntyre writes: SM> Please attach the installer syslog so we have a chance to see what SM> happened. On the installed system, that's in /var/log/installer/syslog What should I give at that initramfs prompt you see that would put it on the screen? Then I could take a

Bug#925582: Allow telling installer about local deb and Package list locations

2019-03-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer User has a USB drive, loaded with $ mount /dev/sdg2 on /var/cache/apt/archives type ext4 /dev/sdg1 on /var/lib/apt/lists type ext4 He takes this drive, along with another drive, containing a Debian installation ISO, to a remote mountain (offline) computer, intending to

Bug#925556: UEFI or not, can't mount /dev

2019-03-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
LS> Clearly the initramfs was able to mount /dev and run fsck, but mounting LS> it to /root/dev to transfer to the real rootfs failed due to a missing LS> directory. So it booted, meaning it is not a https://www.debian.org/releases/stretch/amd64/ch03s06.html.en#UEFI problem...

Bug#925580: Never leave the user staring at an empty screen, even for a second

2019-03-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Here the user is left staring at an empty screen. (Many look that way for a while at the beginning. Even with the latest fastest hardware.) Not for long you might say. But long enough for the user to scratch his head, and then casually get out his cellphone and take a

Bug#925579: User could have just as easily clicked the UEFI or non-UEFI...

2019-03-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer In https://wiki.debian.org/UEFI We read "debian-installer's support for UEFI is mostly contained in two modules. First comes the partman-efi module, and this will be loaded automatically if d-i recognises it has been booted in UEFI mode." The problem here is that on

Bug#857459: cannot scroll to bottom of help on partitioning screen

2017-03-11 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: d-i.debian.org Severity: wishlist Cannot scroll to bottom of 'help on partitioning' screen... too long... no way to read all the way to the bottom.

Bug#852670: dpkg: warning: while removing console-setup-linux, directory '/etc/console-setup' not empty so not removed

2017-01-26 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: console-setup-linux Version: 1.158 dpkg: warning: while removing console-setup-linux, directory '/etc/console-setup' not empty so not removed OK I'll remove by hand -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 4147 2014-02-24 /etc/console-setup/Uni2-Fixed16.psf.gz

Bug#849509: popularity-contest installed momentarily even if user says No

2016-12-28 Thread Dan Jacobson
Well just as if one's country must install a missle defense system just to ask the question if they should install the missle defense system... and then remove the missle defense system... But OK maybe there are some translation strings unavailable from e.g., $ for package in popularity-contest;

Bug#849509: popularity-contest installed momentarily even if user says No

2016-12-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: installation-reports Using DISTRIB_RELEASE="9 (stretch) - installer build 20161212-00:04" the user chooses "No", the default, to the popularity-contest question. He notices through the corner of his eye, something about the package flashing by on the screen anyway! Indeed the logs

Bug#849508: add GO BACK choice to save logs question

2016-12-27 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: installation-reports Using DISTRIB_RELEASE="9 (stretch) - installer build 20161212-00:04" when getting to the question about saving logs, the user is prompted with /mnt . At this point the user wants to GO BACK to choose "open a shell" to inspect what places are in fact mounted.

Bug#849278: zapps USB somehow

2016-12-24 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: os-prober Version: 1.71 With os-prober installed and then running update-grub and grub-install all I know is after rebooting I couldn't use any USB stuff after Debian started the main boot choice. As I depend on a USB keyboard, the only way to regain control of my computer again was to

Bug#582231: dpkg: warning: while removing os-prober, directory '/var/lib/os-prober' not empty so not removed

2016-12-23 Thread Dan Jacobson
found 582231 1.71 thanks Removing os-prober (1.71) ... dpkg: warning: while removing os-prober, directory '/var/lib/os-prober' not empty so not removed # find /var/lib/os-prober -ls 1443133 4 drwxr-xr-x 2 root root 4096 Dec 24 12:21 /var/lib/os-prober 1442408 4

Bug#840351: pstrees

2016-10-11 Thread Dan Jacobson
OK, I have captured both: $ pstree -al During the first occasion: `-aptitude safe-upgrade |-sh -c /usr/sbin/dpkg-preconfigure --apt || true | `-dpkg-preconfigu -w /usr/sbin/dpkg-preconfigure --apt | |-(dpkg-preconfigu)

Bug#840351: user asked same question twice upon upgrade

2016-10-10 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: keyboard-configuration Version: 1.151 During upgrade the user gets asked the same question twice. The first time is at Preconfiguring packages ... The second time is when (viewed with pstree -al): `-frontend -w /usr/share/debconf/frontend

Bug#838332: keyboard-configuration/unsupported_config_layout bad question

2016-09-19 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: keyboard-configuration Version: 1.149 Severity: wishlist We are asked "Keep the current keyboard layout in the configuration file? The current keyboard layout in the configuration file /etc/default/keyboard is defined as ... . Please choose whether you want to keep it. If you choose

Bug#698491: closed by Andreas Glaeser <bugs.andreas.glae...@freenet.de> (old report done)

2016-07-03 Thread Dan Jacobson
I hope the main focus of everything is memory sticks these days.

Bug#780011: say what --install does

2015-03-07 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: busybox $ busybox #or $ busybox --help should say what --install and --list do, as there is no way to cautiously find out when offline. I was going to report this upstream, but there are big browser warnings about https certificate expired on their site. Version 1.23. -- To

Bug#757316: whole disk one big partition is a bad default

2014-09-23 Thread Dan Jacobson
Well OK, I hope they will mostly make swap. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-boot-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org Archive: https://lists.debian.org/87siji3shh@jidanni.org

Bug#762426: setup.exe does work, it just pops up an extra browser window

2014-09-22 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: installation-guide Severity: wishlist Regarding ! 5.1.2. Booting from Windows ! ! To start the installer from Windows, you can either ! ! obtain CD-ROM/DVD-ROM or USB memory stick installation media as described in Section 4.1, “Official Debian GNU/Linux CD/DVD-ROM Sets” respective

Bug#757316: whole disk one big partition is a bad default

2014-08-07 Thread Dan Jacobson
Package: debian-installer Please do not make the default for beginners making the whole disk one big partition anymore. Just leave a little free space just in case... You never know when they might need to tune their unmounted file system etc... -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to

Bug#757316: whole disk one big partition is a bad default

2014-08-07 Thread Dan Jacobson
1% would be fine... Else one day when they e.g., want to upgrade from ext4 to ext5 etc. and face http://www.debian-administration.org/article/643/Migrating_a_live_system_from_ext3_to_ext4_filesystem and end up with Kernel panic – not syncing Attempted to kill init when something goes wrong. All