Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-04 Thread Robert Millan
2011/8/4 Zach JL : > Preallocation of storage.  I would like the option of setting a zfs quotas, > which will limit the amount of storage a given zfs can fill, but not > preallocate and thus reduce the amount available to the rest of the pool. Preallocation is only for legacy file systems. If you

Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-03 Thread Zach JL
> > > It seems that the workflow only permits you to create a pool for creating > > logical volumes rather than using the pool directly. In the wheezy > > installer I tested last weekend, exactly the opposite is true, in that > you > > create a pool to be used directly, albeit in a partition. > >

Bug#635273: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-03 Thread Zach JL
There may have been an ext4 partition there before, but most recently zfs was put on those partitions. Also, I had the installer write a new partition table to the disks, and upon reboot still seemed to detect ext4 instead of zfs. -- Zach

Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-03 Thread Zach JL
> > > This is due to broken permissions in partman-zfs scripts (they got > lost when migrating my new code from Bazaar to Git). It will be fixed > in next upload. > > This does apear to be fixed in the latest iso I pulled today. -- Zach

Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-02 Thread Robert Millan
2011/8/2 Zach JL : > Upon creating a zfs volume on a zpool, I received an error that the creation > of partition #1 has failed.  Though, checking the console I can see system, > system/slash and system/slashs1.  Inspection of the system/slash zfs volume > show that it has type "volume".  I think th

Bug#635273: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-02 Thread Robert Millan
2011/8/2 Zach JL : > ZFS partitions were detected as ext4. Seems like #635273. Did you create an ext4 and overwrite it with zfs afterwards, or vice-versa? -- Robert Millan -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bsd-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listm

Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-02 Thread Robert Millan
Hi Zach, Thank you very much for testing. 2011/8/2 Zach JL : > I was unable to destroy a pool from the menu.  I needed to switch to a shell > and "zpool destroy" to get rid of any existing configuration. Please file a bug on partman-zfs. Keep in mind that I need at least attached syslog output.

Re: Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-08-01 Thread Zach JL
Hi Robert, Thanks for your response. I've pulled down the latest image from: http://cdimage.debian.org/cdimage/daily-builds/daily/arch-latest/kfreebsd-amd64/iso-cd/ to test today. The buildd at this time showed kfreebsd-amd64 as version (9). Here are my notes: ZFS partitions were detected as

Reworked ZFS support in D-I, testers wanted

2011-07-31 Thread Robert Millan
Hi Zach 2011/7/31 Zach JL : > I think that the user should be given a chance to enter a name for the zpool > during installation in the same way that when installing Linux, the user has > a chance to enter the name of a Volume Group for LVM root. I think you'll be interested in: partman-zfs (8)

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2011-02-13 Thread Robert Millan
2011/2/13 Kilian Krause : >> Latest GRUB (in upstream Bazaar, not sure if trunk or some branch) >> supports multi-device ZFS however. > > Not even the one in unstable/experimental? Not currently. > Will that be packaged in the > "near" future or will I have to make my own deb for now? Hopefully.

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2011-02-13 Thread Kilian Krause
Robert, On Sun, Feb 13, 2011 at 07:07:46PM +0100, Robert Millan wrote: > 2011/2/13 Kilian Krause : [...] > > So how do you reckon the RAID1 configuration should be set up? > > You can setup a single-disk zpool and convert it to zRAID1 > afterwards (with "zpool attach"). Trying that I get a Geom

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2011-02-13 Thread Robert Millan
2011/2/13 Kilian Krause : >> - Multi-device arrays are not supported.  If they're RAID1 (mirror), >>   we work around this by selecting the first member and using that for >>   boot later.  For array types where more than one disk is needed, GRUB >>   can't boot.  Using a separate /boot can resolve

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2011-02-13 Thread Kilian Krause
Hi Robert, thanks for the quick reply! On Sun, Feb 13, 2011 at 07:07:46PM +0100, Robert Millan wrote: > 2011/2/13 Kilian Krause : > >> - Multi-device arrays are not supported.  If they're RAID1 (mirror), > >>   we work around this by selecting the first member and using that for > >>   boot later

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2011-02-13 Thread Kilian Krause
Hi Robert, > It's nice to see you guys are making progress about ZFS. I figured a > status report about ZFS support in GRUB would be useful to you. Thanks for the heads up! Coming back to your post now that Squeeze has officially been released with kFreeBSD and ZFS support wit

Re: ZFS support

2010-11-09 Thread Robert Millan
2010/11/9 Colin Watson : > apt-install is not that cheap; it has to set up the target chroot and > then tear it all down again.  Could you please add a bit of state here > to remember when grub_probe has already been called? Ok > I think this should be OK, although I'm (possibly unjustifiably) >

Re: ZFS support

2010-11-09 Thread Colin Watson
On Wed, Sep 01, 2010 at 02:36:17PM +0200, Robert Millan wrote: > This patch adds ZFS support to grub-installer. Thanks for this patch. > diff -ur grub-installer-1.55.old/grub-installer > grub-installer-1.55/grub-installer > --- grub-installer-1.55.old/grub-installer2010

Re: ZFS v28 (Re: ZFS support in GRUB)

2010-09-22 Thread Robert Millan
2010/9/10, Robert Millan : > 2010/8/10, Robert Millan : >> - Only ZFS up to (and including) version 14 is supported. [...] complete >> support for ZFS in root isn't currently being worked on. We need >> help in this area. > > Taking [1] into account I guess there will be interest for v28 supp

ZFS v28 (Re: ZFS support in GRUB)

2010-09-10 Thread Robert Millan
2010/8/10, Robert Millan : > - Only ZFS up to (and including) version 14 is supported. [...] complete > support for ZFS in root isn't currently being worked on. We need > help in this area. Taking [1] into account I guess there will be interest for v28 support in GRUB sometime in the near fu

Bug#595759: ZFS support (partman-zfs)

2010-09-06 Thread Robert Millan
Package: debian-installer Severity: wishlist Tags: patch This script converts partman-ufs into partman-zfs. Patches for parted (#595007) and grub-installer (#595152) are also required to build a working installer. -- System Information: Debian Release: squeeze/sid APT prefers testing APT pol

Bug#595152: ZFS support

2010-09-01 Thread Robert Millan
Package: grub-installer Version: 1.55 Severity: wishlist Tags: patch This patch adds ZFS support to grub-installer. Note: findfs change is required because mount output only gives zpool name, not the device associated with it. The other changes should be obvious. -- System Information: Debian

Bug#595007: ZFS support

2010-08-31 Thread Robert Millan
Package: parted Version: 2.3-2 Severity: wishlist Tags: patch This patch (already sent upstream with copyright assignment) adds support for detecting ZFS filesystems. I adjusted it to the Debian package. Would it be possible to include it in the release? It is very unintrusive and is one of

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2010-08-12 Thread Aurelien Jarno
On Wed, Aug 11, 2010 at 06:01:26PM -0400, Tuco wrote: > This is very nice. Right now I'm having some trouble with zpool, but > I'll try to boot from a ZFS root with GRUB as soon as I get the > chance. > > On 8/10/10, Robert Millan wrote: > > - Only ZFS up to (and including) version 14 is supporte

Re: ZFS support in GRUB

2010-08-11 Thread Tuco
This is very nice. Right now I'm having some trouble with zpool, but I'll try to boot from a ZFS root with GRUB as soon as I get the chance. On 8/10/10, Robert Millan wrote: > - Only ZFS up to (and including) version 14 is supported. I just checked, version 14 is in kernel 8.1. Is this the versi

ZFS support in GRUB

2010-08-10 Thread Robert Millan
[ Please CC me on your replies ] Hi, It's nice to see you guys are making progress about ZFS. I figured a status report about ZFS support in GRUB would be useful to you. GRUB has complete support for ZFS in current trunk, provided that the contrib ZFS code in grub-extras is overlaid (as