Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-08-24 Thread Brian Potkin
tags 616718 + moreinfo thanks On Sun 06 Mar 2011 at 13:28:13 -0800, Aaron Barany wrote: > Package: cups > Version: 1.4.4-7 > Severity: important > > After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from > "http://localhost:631"; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first pa

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: > I think we are agreed though that it is > upstream which would have to deal with it. No, I disagree with that. It is affected users or kind hackers working on their behalf that would have to deal with it, by writing a patch and reporting this upstr

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:30:48 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Brian Potkin wrote: > > On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > > >> Design bugs are still bugs. :) > > > > Indeed. But that isn't the substance of this bug report. > > Ok, let's consider this for a second. Th

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: > On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: >> Design bugs are still bugs. :) > > Indeed. But that isn't the substance of this bug report. Ok, let's consider this for a second. The original submitter reported that there were (to him) mysterious "Forbidden"

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Brian Potkin wrote: > > > The 'Forbidden' message came as a result of the design of CUPS. In that > > sense it is not a bug, unless the implementation is lacking. The easy > > fix, of course, is lpadmin membership. > > Design bugs ar

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
tags 616718 + upstream quit Brian Potkin wrote: > The 'Forbidden' message came as a result of the design of CUPS. In that > sense it is not a bug, unless the implementation is lacking. The easy > fix, of course, is lpadmin membership. Design bugs are still bugs. :) Thanks for investigating.

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 13:52:55 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Brian Potkin wrote: > > > Now you try again. The first stage is not repeated because PAM is to be > > trusted and would get upset if CUPS kept querying its decisions. Which > > is why you do not get the dialogue box back. CUPS already

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: > Now you try again. The first stage is not repeated because PAM is to be > trusted and would get upset if CUPS kept querying its decisions. Which > is why you do not get the dialogue box back. CUPS already knows your > status regarding group membership so just keeps pointing t

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
Hello Jonathan, You wrote: > so presumably I ought to add myself to group lpadmin. But in any > event, the inability to get back to step 2 (the dialog box allowing > me to choose a username and password) is puzzling. If you repeated your first two steps but in step 3 gave an incorrect user/pass

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2011-03-24 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Hi, Aaron Barany wrote: > After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from > "http://localhost:631"; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first page > before I have a chance to add any information. I tried something similar with cups 1.4.6-3. Here's what I did: 1. Visi

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2011-03-06 Thread Aaron Barany
Package: cups Version: 1.4.4-7 Severity: important After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from "http://localhost:631"; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first page before I have a chance to add any information. -- System Information: Debian Release: 6.0 APT pre