Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-02-20 Thread Robie Basak
reopen 736087 thanks On Thu, Feb 20, 2014 at 02:39:16PM +0100, Felix Geyer wrote: > dh_apparmor is still only called on Ubuntu: > if [ "$(DISTRIBUTION)" = "Ubuntu" ]; then \ > dh_apparmor -pmysql-server-5.5 --profile-name=usr.sbin.mysqld; \ > fi > > That means all the postinst

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-02-20 Thread intrigeri
Control: reopen -1 Felix Geyer wrote (20 Feb 2014 13:39:16 GMT) : > dh_apparmor is still only called on Ubuntu: > if [ "$(DISTRIBUTION)" = "Ubuntu" ]; then \ > dh_apparmor -pmysql-server-5.5 --profile-name=usr.sbin.mysqld; \ > fi > That means all the postinst magic is missing

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-02-20 Thread Felix Geyer
dh_apparmor is still only called on Ubuntu: if [ "$(DISTRIBUTION)" = "Ubuntu" ]; then \ dh_apparmor -pmysql-server-5.5 --profile-name=usr.sbin.mysqld; \ fi That means all the postinst magic is missing to create /etc/apparmor.d/local/usr.sbin.mysqld and load the profile.

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-02-10 Thread intrigeri
Robie Basak wrote (10 Feb 2014 14:08:59 GMT) : >> You certainly will need to prevent the installation of a default apparmor >> profile when there is an existing /etc/mysql/my.cnf installed by the >> user. Otherwise things will certainly break if any stuff has moved to >> different directories. > I

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-02-10 Thread Robie Basak
I've just submitted a patch for this: http://lists.alioth.debian.org/pipermail/pkg-mysql-maint/2014-February/006409.html I'd like to counter some of your points, as I think it does make sense for Debian to cover this. I do have an ulterior motive here, though, which is that carrying this in Debia

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: Bug#736087: Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-21 Thread Otto Kekäläinen
Hello, 2014/1/21 Kristian Nielsen : >> What do you think? > > I think those are valid arguments. Thanks for the discussion. I haven't picked my view yet, I need to do some testing first once other priorities are completed first. - Otto -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@list

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-21 Thread Kristian Nielsen
intrigeri writes: > Hi, > > Kristian Nielsen wrote (21 Jan 2014 09:18:05 GMT) : >> In my experience, there are a lot of problems with installing an apparmor >> profile by default for the MySQL server. This is from 4 years of experience >> maintaining MariaDB .deb packages. > > Thank you for this

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-21 Thread intrigeri
Hi, Kristian Nielsen wrote (21 Jan 2014 09:18:05 GMT) : > In my experience, there are a lot of problems with installing an apparmor > profile by default for the MySQL server. This is from 4 years of experience > maintaining MariaDB .deb packages. Thank you for this very useful input. I want to co

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-21 Thread Kristian Nielsen
intrig...@debian.org writes: > debian/rules only installs the usr.sbin.mysqld AppArmor profile on > Ubuntu (no idea why this is done in override_dh_installlogrotate-arch, > by the way; looks like a buggy merge to me, but anyway, that's > off-topic for now). In my experience, there are a lot of pr

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-19 Thread intrigeri
Clint Byrum wrote (19 Jan 2014 16:22:19 GMT) : > It is in fact just an oversight during merging changes back from Ubuntu. > James Page has promised to me that there will be a concerted effort to > get Ubuntu and Debian in sync in the very near term, and that would > include the AppArmor profile. V

Bug#736087: [debian-mysql] Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-19 Thread Clint Byrum
Excerpts from intrigeri's message of 2014-01-19 08:05:27 -0800: > Source: mysql-5.5 > Severity: wishlist > Version: 5.5.33+dfsg-1 > > Hi, > > debian/rules only installs the usr.sbin.mysqld AppArmor profile on > Ubuntu (no idea why this is done in override_dh_installlogrotate-arch, > by the way; l

Bug#736087: mysql-5.5: Please install AppArmor profile on Debian too

2014-01-19 Thread intrigeri
Source: mysql-5.5 Severity: wishlist Version: 5.5.33+dfsg-1 Hi, debian/rules only installs the usr.sbin.mysqld AppArmor profile on Ubuntu (no idea why this is done in override_dh_installlogrotate-arch, by the way; looks like a buggy merge to me, but anyway, that's off-topic for now). Debian has