Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-08-01 Thread Martin Pitt
Hello Paul and lintian maintainers, Paul Gevers [2018-07-30 21:37 +0200]: > Please, update your autopkgtest to actually test the binary package(s) > as installed. You're welcome to have this test *additionally* to actual > tests. I don't really see much point in explicitly encouraging /bin/true t

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Chris Lamb
tags 905030 + pending thanks Implemented in Git, pending upload: https://salsa.debian.org/lintian/lintian/commit/bce0c1fb542a5efedd56bb07348ebb09d1c39003 checks/testsuite.desc | 16 checks/testsuite.pm | 4

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Sebastiaan Couwenberg
On Tue, 31 Jul 2018 17:57:07 +0200 Paul Gevers wrote: > On 31-07-18 16:55, Chris Lamb wrote: > >> Rather unconstructively, they refuse to fix it until lintian has the > >> warning [2]. > > > > That seems.. strange. At the very least, Lintian is not Policy. But lintian is the reason that the autop

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Paul Gevers
Hi Chris, On 31-07-18 16:55, Chris Lamb wrote: >> Rather unconstructively, they refuse to fix it until lintian has the >> warning [2]. > > That seems.. strange. At the very least, Lintian is not Policy. Ack. I filed 6 bugs today against packages in their team (the ones currently trying to migrat

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Paul, > Rather unconstructively, they refuse to fix it until lintian has the > warning [2]. That seems.. strange. At the very least, Lintian is not Policy. Unrelated to the above, do you feel there any real fear that a /bin/ true would simply be replaced with something else if a maintainer sa

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Stuart Prescott
> >> For this proposal to make sense, all deployed autopkgtests must > >> actually test the package involved to some extent. > > > > I fully ACK and understand the issue and background but just to be more > > effective priority-wise are you aware of how many packages, if any, > > are violating thi

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-31 Thread Paul Gevers
Hi Chris, On 31-07-18 05:16, Chris Lamb wrote: >> For this proposal to make sense, all deployed autopkgtests must >> actually test the package involved to some extent. > > I fully ACK and understand the issue and background but just to be more > effective priority-wise are you aware of how many p

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-30 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Paul, > For this proposal to make sense, all deployed autopkgtests must > actually test the package involved to some extent. I fully ACK and understand the issue and background but just to be more effective priority-wise are you aware of how many packages, if any, are violating this right now?

Bug#905030: lintian: please verify debian/tests/control contains more tests than "Test-Command: /bin/true"

2018-07-30 Thread Paul Gevers
Package: lintian Version: 2.5.93 Severity: normal X-Debbugs-CC: debian...@lists.debian.org User: debian...@lists.debian.org Usertags: issue Dear lintian maintainers, The Release Team has expressed their wish [1] that autopkgtest does not simply contain /bin/true as test command: """ For this prop