Package: atftpd
Version: 0.7.dfsg-3
Priority: serious
Justification: Policy violation, section 3.6

Atftpd Provides: the 'tftpd' virtual package, but that package is not listed
in the canonical virtual packages list at
http://www.debian.org/doc/packaging-manuals/virtual-package-names-list.txt

This is a Policy violation and, what is worst, induces users to confusion as
this (and tftpd-hpa) do not provide the same behaviour. For starters, atftpd
users /tftpboot as the standard (non-FHS) location for files, whileas
tftpd-hpa uses /srv/tftpboot and tftpd uses /var/lib/tftpboot

Please either remove the provides or get together with other maintainers of
tftpd daemons and determine what is the common interface (and location of
files) so that users that install a package Providing: tftpd can make
reasonable assumptions as to its behaviour and *then* ask debian-policy to add
'tftpd' as a virtual package.

I would really encourage you to follow the second road, even if more complex,
as it would be better overall for all our users.

Regards

Javier

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to