Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-15 Thread Remco Blaakmeer
On Mon, 15 Jun 1998, Santiago Vila wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- On 14 Jun 1998, Guy Maor wrote: passwd is required and that is enough. You can assume that all required packages are always on the system. I disagree. Since you are able to remove a

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-15 Thread Santiago Vila
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- On 14 Jun 1998, Guy Maor wrote: passwd is required and that is enough. You can assume that all required packages are always on the system. I disagree. Since you are able to remove a required-but-non-essential package and dpkg does not complain,

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-14 Thread Guy Maor
James Troup [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: My original objection was going to be base around the fact that passwd is Essential, but it turns out it isn't, my bad. I'd hate to be part of the current `Let's make foo Essential: yes and part of the base system, in fact let's make it the kernel'

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-10 Thread Scott Hanson
Martin Schulze [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:55:53PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: ---snip--- The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're included in the passwd package.

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-10 Thread Martin Schulze
On Wed, Jun 10, 1998 at 07:49:48AM +0200, Scott Hanson wrote: The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're included in the passwd package. They might use configuration files that might not be

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-09 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:55:53PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: I have moved msql 2.0.3-4 into Incoming/REJECT - Forwarded message from James Troup [EMAIL PROTECTED] - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Martin Schulze) writes: * Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used

RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
I have moved msql 2.0.3-4 into Incoming/REJECT - Forwarded message from James Troup [EMAIL PROTECTED] - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Martin Schulze) writes: * Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used in the preinst. You're meant to obtain a consensus on

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Santiago Vila
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- On Mon, 8 Jun 1998, Martin Schulze wrote: [...] Does anybody object? The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're included in the passwd package. They might use

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread James Troup
Martin Schulze [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: * Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used in the preinst. Does anybody object? My original objection was going to be base around the fact that passwd is Essential, but it turns out it isn't, my bad. I'd hate to be

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:17:52PM +0100, James Troup wrote: Martin Schulze [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: * Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used in the preinst. Does anybody object? My original objection was going to be base around the fact that passwd

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Richard Braakman
Martin Schulze wrote: The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and groupadd. Why not do it in the postinst, at configure time? Then a normal dependency is enough. If the user or group does not exist on the system, dpkg will use the numeric IDs instead. Richard

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 02:26:09PM +0200, Richard Braakman wrote: Martin Schulze wrote: The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and groupadd. Why not do it in the postinst, at configure time? Then a normal dependency is enough. Because the uid should be present