Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Wouter Verhelst
On Thu, Oct 28, 2004 at 05:10:04PM +0200, Frank Küster wrote: > Shaun Jackman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Perhaps that's true -- I must do a little reading. However, if you > > upload a package to contrib that build-depends on a package not in > > contrib or non-free, you'll get a FTBFS RC bu

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Oded Shimon
On Thursday 28 October 2004 15:15, Thaddeus H. Black wrote: > Hello Oded. > > > > Again, good luck. If and when you find an > appropriate sponsor, let me know the good news. Wow, honestly, that was some damn great advice... And it does sound very accurate and I do understand it. I don't know if

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Frank Küster
Shaun Jackman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Perhaps that's true -- I must do a little reading. However, if you > upload a package to contrib that build-depends on a package not in > contrib or non-free, you'll get a FTBFS RC bug filed against you > before you blink. Are there any (inofficial) bui

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Ben Burton
> However, if you > upload a package to contrib that build-depends on a package not in > contrib or non-free, you'll get a FTBFS RC bug filed against you > before you blink. Hmm, I didn't, back in the days when regina-normal built against java2 (which wasn't in the archive at the time). Though t

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Adeodato Simó
* Erik Schanze [Wed, 27 Oct 2004 18:31:35 +0200]: > If your program depends on MPlayer, it must go into non-free. > If your program depends on a program in non-free, it must go into contrib. > But MPlayer isn't even in non-free. not exactly. packages in contrib can depend on packages not availa

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-28 Thread Oded Shimon
On Thursday 28 October 2004 01:57, Shaun Jackman wrote: > > A package in main must not depend on any software outside of main, and > > must be DFSG-free; A package in contrib must be DFSG-free; A package in > > non-free must be legally distributable by Debian. > > > > There are no further restricti

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Shaun Jackman
> That's not true. There are many packages in contrib which do not have > all their dependencies in non-free. E.g., the bunch of java packages > which do not work with anything but a non-free java compiler -- a java > compiler which Debian itself cannot distribute (and therefor is not in > non-free

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Christoffer Sawicki
> According to that, MPlayer doesn't need to be in the Debian archives for my > program to be in contrib!... Yes, that's true. Please note that a package called `mozilla-mplayer' [0] is in the Debian archive. [0] http://packages.debian.org/unstable/misc/mozilla-mplayer */ Christoffer Sawicki <[

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Erik Schanze
Oded Shimon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > On Wednesday 27 October 2004 05:23, Daniel Burrows wrote: > OK, either I am misreading, or you just prooved me right: > > * free packages which require [..] packages which are not in our archive at > > all for compilation or execution > > My program == free prog

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Ben Burton
> Yup, thats exactly what I thought. In which case, my program does have a > chance to be in contrib. which brings me to my original question, what should > I do to find a sponsor?... I believe I've maxed out my available resources... It might be that you need to wait until you've gone through

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Oded Shimon
On Wednesday 27 October 2004 11:05, Wouter Verhelst wrote: > That's not true. There are many packages in contrib which do not have > all their dependencies in non-free. E.g., the bunch of java packages > which do not work with anything but a non-free java compiler -- a java > compiler which Debian

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Wouter Verhelst
On Tue, Oct 26, 2004 at 10:52:58PM +0200, Oded Shimon wrote: > On Tuesday 26 October 2004 22:37, Shaun Jackman wrote: > > For your package to go in contrib, your dependency -- mplayer -- must > > exist in non-free. > Really? I didn't know this. That's not true. There are many packages in contrib w

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-27 Thread Oded Shimon
On Wednesday 27 October 2004 05:23, Daniel Burrows wrote: > > That's not surprising. Policy says (section 2.2.2, "The contrib > section"): > > Examples of packages which would be included in contrib or non-US/contrib > are: > > * free packages which require contrib, non-free packages or pack

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-26 Thread Daniel Burrows
On Tuesday 26 October 2004 04:52 pm, Oded Shimon wrote: > On Tuesday 26 October 2004 22:37, Shaun Jackman wrote: > > For your package to go in contrib, your dependency -- mplayer -- must > > exist in non-free. > > Really? I didn't know this. That's not surprising. Policy says (section 2.2.2, "T

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-26 Thread Oded Shimon
On Wednesday 27 October 2004 00:00, Shaun Jackman wrote: > Sorry, no link. The basic issue, though, is that MPEG 1/2/4 encoding > is encumbered by patents. OK, so my question is, what about xine? How come xine can be in Debian? AFAIK xine can open mpeg1 mpeg2 and mpeg4. > > Wait, when you said th

Re: RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-26 Thread Oded Shimon
On Tuesday 26 October 2004 22:37, Shaun Jackman wrote: > For your package to go in contrib, your dependency -- mplayer -- must > exist in non-free. Really? I didn't know this. > Due to patent issues, mplayer cannot go in non-free I've heard of that.. if possible, I'm curious what the "issues" are

RFS: kmenc15 - An advanced Qt/KDE MEncoder frontend.

2004-10-24 Thread Oded Shimon
Hi. This is no longer an RFS, I posted this RFS here quite a while ago, this is now a "plea" for: What should I do? My program is an MEncoder frontend which depends on MPlayer, if I am not mistaken, that means it belongs in contrib. I have completed a Debian package, have been looking for a s