Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-18 Thread Jeff Green
I dropped on this purely by accident and if I have followed up incorrectly I apologise. There is very old legal precedence that the reporting of public sporting events and the scores etc of the games is in the public domain. Once you have made a move in chess (or played a shot in a cricket match wh

Re: Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-13 Thread Simon Waters
David Starner wrote: > > On Sat, Apr 13, 2002 at 07:20:52PM +0200, Lukas Geyer wrote: > > However, the gnuchess book consists of raw game scores, so my conclusion > > is that it is not subject to copyright and it is in the public domain. (As > > far as I know, the gnuchess book was not put togethe

Re: Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-13 Thread David Starner
On Sat, Apr 13, 2002 at 07:20:52PM +0200, Lukas Geyer wrote: > However, the gnuchess book consists of raw game scores, so my conclusion > is that it is not subject to copyright and it is in the public domain. (As > far as I know, the gnuchess book was not put together with some "unique > criteria",

Re: Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-13 Thread Lukas Geyer
On 13 Apr 2002, Henning Makholm wrote: > The more difficult problem is the legal status of each individual game > itself? Do the chess players who played it have a sort of copyright? > Surely, they have made real intellectual decisions about which piece > to move where, but is that a decision abou

Re: Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-13 Thread Henning Makholm
Scripsit Joe Drew <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Get him to clarify it absolutely, telling him it's a very big issue for > Debian, and don't upload till you have the official word from him. I don't think the problem is that easy. Sure, the guy who collected the game may (in some jurisdictions) have sort

Re: Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-12 Thread Joe Drew
On Fri, 2002-04-12 at 12:28, Lukas Geyer wrote: > I think uncommented Chess games are effectively free of > copyright restrictions. They are collaborative performance art > or some such bizarre legal status. > > I probably ought to clarify the legal position and add it to the > FAQ. > >

Legal status of chess game collections

2002-04-12 Thread Lukas Geyer
I am just working on repackaging gnuchess to split it into gnuchess and gnuchess-book. The problem with gnuchess-book is that it is basically a large collection of uncommented chess games in PGN format. It used to be included in gnuchess but now it has been separated mainly due to its size. However