Re: Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-08 Thread Benjamin Mesing
Hello > > 'packagesearch' is a package which uses a plugin architecture. Each > > plugin provides a way to search for packages, e.g. doing a full text > > search, searching by filenames or orphaned packages. All plugins are > > shipped together with the main application in a single > > package. Ho

Re: Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-05 Thread Manoj Srivastava
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007 22:16:35 +0200, Benjamin Mesing <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > Hello, the latest message on debian-devel-announce made me rethink my > decision for the dependencies for my package 'packagesearch'. > Having read the policy again and again and also through the recent > debian-deve

Re: Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-04 Thread Carl Fürstenberg
I don't know if this is in line with policy, but I would split the plugins to one package per plugin, then let each of those packages provide "packagesearch-plugin", and let packagesearch depend on "packagesearch-plugin". On 8/3/07, Don Armstrong <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Fri, 03 Aug 2007, B

Re: Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-03 Thread Don Armstrong
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007, Benjamin Mesing wrote: > As for 'packagesearch', even if no additional package is installed, > there is always the full text search available - so the package by > itself is useful. Thus there is no need to *Depends:* on deborphan > or apt-file. Also, I could imagine a 'usual'

Re: Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-03 Thread Shachar Shemesh
Benjamin Mesing wrote: > * a plugin architecture package (which provides merely the > framework for additional functionality) without any additional > is useless by itself so it requires at least one plugin. > According to the policy wording this should qualify for a >

Suggests vs. Recommends

2007-08-03 Thread Benjamin Mesing
Hello, the latest message on debian-devel-announce made me rethink my decision for the dependencies for my package 'packagesearch'. Having read the policy again and again and also through the recent debian-devel thread [1], I am not sure whether to use *Recommends* or *Suggests*. 'packagesearch'