Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-12 Thread Anthony Campbell
On 11 Jun 2002, Sean 'Shaleh' Perry wrote: > > On 11-Jun-2002 Dan Jacobson wrote: > > [Debian's default installation gives 2 year old emacs and 6 year old > > non-GNU awk, while sporting the "GNU/Linux" branding] > > > > Summary: Dan says the debian install process should at least > > ask/inform

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread synthespian
On Tue, Jun 11, 2002 at 07:01:47AM -0700, Sean 'Shaleh' Perry wrote: > > On 11-Jun-2002 Dan Jacobson wrote: > > [Debian's default installation gives 2 year old emacs and 6 year old > > non-GNU awk, while sporting the "GNU/Linux" branding] > > > > Summary: Dan says the debian install process shoul

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Kirk Strauser
At 2002-06-11T19:39:15Z, "Derrick 'dman' Hudson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Well put, Kirk. There is no problem (other than length of a release > cycle, but this isn't the place to fix that). Thanks. I suspect the OP was a troll, but I just couldn't resist. :) -- Kirk Strauser The Strause

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Derrick 'dman' Hudson
On Tue, Jun 11, 2002 at 09:04:50AM -0500, Kirk Strauser wrote: | At 2002-06-11T12:24:09Z, Dan Jacobson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: | > I'm talking about the most basic of user. All these names are foreign. | > He has just inserted the 8 woody CD's given to him by a friend and is | > following ins

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Sean 'Shaleh' Perry
On 11-Jun-2002 James Troup wrote: > "Sean 'Shaleh' Perry" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >> as I said, two years ago I found that random awk scripts worked >> better with mawk than gawk, this has likely changed. > > Err, actually you claimed that this (i.e. 'random awk scripts > work[ing] better'

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread James Troup
"Sean 'Shaleh' Perry" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > as I said, two years ago I found that random awk scripts worked > better with mawk than gawk, this has likely changed. Err, actually you claimed that this (i.e. 'random awk scripts work[ing] better') is why mawk is the default, but that's comple

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Sean 'Shaleh' Perry
On 11-Jun-2002 James Troup wrote: > "Sean 'Shaleh' Perry" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >> As to the specific awk issue, when we made the choice mawk worked better on >> more scripts than gawk did. This may have changed in the last 2 years or so >> but was still valid when potato came out. > >

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Joey Hess
So if anyone wants to have any bearing on issues like which emacs the tasks select, you need to subscribe to debian-testing and respond to requests to test the task system. Coming sniveling and ccing BS to rms 6 months too late is not very effective. The tasks will select emacs21 in the major relea

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Paul Smith
%% Alan Shutko <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: as> Sean 'Shaleh' Perry <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >> For most new users emacs20 is just as good as 21. The two large >> changes in 21 for newbies were a better X front end and console font >> locking. as> Also, better menus, toolbar, toolt

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Alan Shutko
Sean 'Shaleh' Perry <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > For most new users emacs20 is just as good as 21. The two large > changes in 21 for newbies were a better X front end and console font > locking. Also, better menus, toolbar, tooltips, automatic hscroll, hourglass, sane delete key setup (especia

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread James Troup
"Sean 'Shaleh' Perry" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > As to the specific awk issue, when we made the choice mawk worked better on > more scripts than gawk did. This may have changed in the last 2 years or so > but was still valid when potato came out. Err, no. Mawk is the default because (since a

Re: Debian is not GNU (at least current GNU)

2002-06-11 Thread Mathias Gygax
On Tue, Jun 11, 2002 at 11:01:47AM -0300, Klaus Imgrund wrote: > Looks fine to me. As basic user I don't even know what GNU is so I am > not too concerned about it. if you ever used ls, find or grep, you are already a user of GNU. the chances are big, that you use such basic tools. debian embrace

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Kirk Strauser
At 2002-06-11T12:24:09Z, Dan Jacobson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Summary: Dan says the debian install process should at least ask/inform > the user that he is not getting current official GNU tools despite the GNU > on the box, and in some cases [awk] he isn't even getting a GNU tool. You kno

RE: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Sean 'Shaleh' Perry
On 11-Jun-2002 Dan Jacobson wrote: > [Debian's default installation gives 2 year old emacs and 6 year old > non-GNU awk, while sporting the "GNU/Linux" branding] > > Summary: Dan says the debian install process should at least > ask/inform the user that he is not getting current official GNU tool

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Ivo Wever
Dan wrote: I'm thinking of the most basic user that sees the shiny GNU/Linux label and, thinking that debian is "more GNU" than the other Linux distributions, chooses debian, only to find out that if he wants GNU versions [gawk], or current versions [emacs21] he must do fancy maneuvers [apt-get]

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Colin Watson
On Tue, Jun 11, 2002 at 08:24:09PM +0800, Dan Jacobson wrote: > Why not put the fancy maneuvers burden on the experts? Why not > install current _official_ versions of all GNU tools by default? If > there is something wrong with those tools then "go file a bug" with > their maintainers. So, why

Re: Debian is not GNU [at least current GNU]

2002-06-11 Thread Hall Stevenson
> [Debian's default installation gives 2 year old emacs > and 6 year old non-GNU awk, while sporting the > "GNU/Linux" branding] > [snip] > > Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Let's hope he gets s much mail that he can't respond to the list about this (non-)issue !! Regards Hall -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, em