[Bug 181244] Re: libcdio GPL/license violation

2010-01-13 Thread Reinhard Tartler
I'm attaching the current debian/copyright file that is currently included in lucid's libcdio10 package. While it does not show the license change (which needs to be handled upstream), it does state: - Joerg Schilling as one of the copyright holders - the license is GPLv3 or later. indeed the

[Bug 181244] Re: libcdio GPL/license violation

2010-01-14 Thread Schily
The original problem has not been fixed: - it is even worse now as the current libcdio is published under a supposed GPLv3 or any later while it contains code that was published under "GPLv2 only". The authors of the related code have not been asked and would not give their OK for a licens

[Bug 181244] Re: libcdio GPL/license violation

2010-01-14 Thread Mackenzie Morgan
For gst-plugins-ugly0.10: The COPYING file in http://gstreamer.freedesktop.org/src/gst-plugins-ugly/gst-plugins-ugly-0.10.13.tar.gz and in the package in Lucid and the debian/copyright in Lucid all agree that the license is LGPLv2.1+ For libcdio: The COPYING file in http://ftp.gnu.org/gnu/libcd

[Bug 181244] Re: libcdio GPL/license violation

2012-11-20 Thread Rockyb
cdda2wav code in libcdio is only for its paranoia library. When we became aware of the mixing of licenses, the paranoia portion was split off from libcdio and put into a separate package and the two packages have separate licenses. So again and more specifically, libcdio version 0.90 from Oct 27,

[Bug 181244] Re: libcdio GPL/license violation

2011-07-31 Thread Schily
Let me repeat again: The maintainer of libcdio admits that libcdio contains code from cdda2wav and the code crom cdda2wav is available under GPLv2-only or under CDDL but not under different licenses. Note: this is an official statement from the cdda2wav author. BTW: This is not the only software