Dear all,

Most files we come across these days (e.g. png graphics, mp4 video, html
file) are meant to be consumed in 2 ways: reviewing and editing.

For example, to review a png, you'd simply use an image viewer software
(e.g. Shotwell). To edit it, however, you'd probably need an editor (e.g.
GIMP). A reviewer is supposed to load up the file quickly and get user to
review it as soon as possible. An editor usually loads up much slower with
full capability to manipulate the file.


*Situation*

In Nautlius, you can set 1 default application for each filetype. You may
open the file with the "Open with XXXXX" option on the right-click menu.

Since there is only 1 default, you can either set the editor or reviewer.
Not both. If you want to open it with the other application, you need to
use "Open with other application", select the application and press the
"Select" button on the top right corner.


*Suggestions*

There are multiple ways to improve the situation:

   1. Expose the "Other Application" on right click. Instead of having to
   use the "Open with other application" pop up, user could access the
   suggested applications through a secondary menu on right click.

   If I remember it correctly, Nautilus used to work like this.

   2. Have Nautilus support 2 different defaults for some file type (if not
   all): "Editor" and "Reviewer". On the right click menu, shows the action
   verbs "View" and "Edit" (instead of "Open with XXXXX").

I personally think (2) is a cleaner design, but it introduces more
complications into the "File Properties" pop up.

Please tell me what you think. Thanks.


Koala Yeung
_______________________________________________
desktop-devel-list mailing list
desktop-devel-list@gnome.org
https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/desktop-devel-list

Reply via email to