Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

users@ list has virtually no traffic/subscribers - most of the discussions are on slack (but it's both devel and users). I am also in favour of moving to Github Discussions. The only potential "problem" is that users might not be on Github - but I think it's a small barrier. On Thu, Aug 27, 2020 a

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

Why not users@ mailing list: * I personally don't currently subscribe to users@ because of email overload * I didn't subscribe to users@ for very long as a new users, because I felt that I could get better support elsewhere than from others on that list. Why not Slack: * I do visit Slack to try

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

*ASF Infra *has said the following: Note that github discussion are NOT to be used for anything other than user help. As is the policy of the Foundation, all code-related discussions and project management activities MUST be reflected to an ASF mailing list. What do you'll think now? I saw we kee

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

I mean I wouldn't want to drop Slack, it is so convenient for quick conversations, especially between committers too. I think Slack can co-exist with Github Discussions (GD), GD just replaces us...@airflow.apache.org On Mon, Aug 24, 2020, 21:14 Jarek Potiuk wrote: > I am all for moving especiall

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

I am all for moving especially looking at the roadmap: https://github.com/github/roadmap/issues/104 (Q4 2020). The question is whether it will serve all the purposes that slack serves now and whether we can just abandon slack in one go? J, On Mon, Aug 24, 2020 at 7:30 PM Tomasz Urbaszek wrote:

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

We had a small chat about this on slack: https://apache-airflow.slack.com/archives/CCPRP7943/p159838037700 I personally think that if our request for paid Slack is not accepted we should consider moving to Github Discussion. Even if we got paid plan, I would be in favor of migrating as we don'

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

I agree and I share the same concern. But I see it as a drop-in replacement for the us...@airflow.apache.org list and is mostly similar to a forum which will be indexed by Search engine unlike Slack. Also as we are on a free plan with Slack, we can't see history :( -- We have asked Slack if they c

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

The only concern I can think of is it seems serving identical purpose of what Slack is serving at this moment (correct me if I’m wrong please). Then attentions (especially from folks who nicely volunteer to answer questions in community) would be distributed unnecessarily. XD > On 24 Aug 2020

[DISCUSS] Enable Github Discussions on Apache Airflow Github Repo

Hi all, I know most of us might have already heard or read about Github Discussions . I noticed Apache Couchdb has been already using it: https://github.co