Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-16 Thread Chinmay Kolhatkar
Added the subtasks. I just realized that by mistake I created the jiras in APEXMALHAR instead of APEXCORE. Is there a way to move the jiras to different project? Let me know otherwise, I'll close these jiras and recreate new ones in APEXCORE. Thanks, Chinmay. On Sat, Jun 16, 2018 at 7:50 PM Chin

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-16 Thread Chinmay Kolhatkar
Hi All, I've created following jiras encompassing the requirements (To be picked up in order): https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/APEXMALHAR-2558 https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/APEXMALHAR-2559 I'll start adding subtasks for subitems mentioned in the jira. I'll also create the feature b

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-16 Thread Chinmay Kolhatkar
So here is how it'll be: 1. ReactJS application can be compiled for production builds. The output is set of html+css+compressed js files. It can also output a war file directly (I think). 2. The react app will have a configuration switch to allow user to set the baseUrl. Default value will be "/ws/

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-14 Thread Pramod Immaneni
I don't think they would be reusable as is without any changes externally as the application context would not be available. Also externally you would want to have a different kind of application that aggregates across multiple applications. Thanks On Thu, Jun 14, 2018 at 10:24 AM Vlad Rozov wro

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-14 Thread Vlad Rozov
If it is a set of static files that use existing REST API to display information in a browser, where they will be hosted is irrelevant. They can be hosted by stram, but it should be possible to host them externally without making modificaitons. If this is the case, I don't have any objections t

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-13 Thread Chinmay Kolhatkar
Hi Team, I agree with Thomas. The main focus of this proposal was to provide a UI layer using existing REST APIs. I think we should first focus on providing a meaningful UI served by AM to user using the same existing REST APIs. If in general, there is a agreement for the proposal, I can proceed

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-12 Thread Thomas Weise
Looks like there is some disconnect in this thread, a few replies express concerns that the proposal IMO doesn't imply. There is already a REST API that backs all of the CLI functionality. Modern UIs run in the browser, and so what was proposed (unless I misunderstood) would be based on the same

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-12 Thread Shubhrajyoti Mohapatra
Hi Community, I would like to propose a slightly different approach on having an UI for Apex. The details are below: 1. This involves having an external web-server installed along side of apexCli. We will basically mimic all the functionalities that apexCli currently provides. 2. We

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-11 Thread Vlad Rozov
IMO it will be hard to provide UI that meets everyone expectation. An external webUI can serve two goals 1. provide reference UI implementation 2. ensure that REST API have all necessary entry points by embedding webUI directly into stram it will be tempting to shortcut some calls to use stram

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-11 Thread Pramod Immaneni
I too think that a comprehensive UI works better standalone but given that stram already runs a webapp server, provides web services and RM provides a proxy with mapped url space for it, we can extend stram to provide better visual output. Overall I am +1 on the idea. On Mon, Jun 11, 2018 at 8:59

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-11 Thread Vlad Rozov
Clarification: I am -0 on making UI part of the stram. I am +1 on providing reference webUI application outside of the stram. Thank you, Vlad On 6/9/18 07:05, Vlad Rozov wrote: -0: stram provides REST API to query runtime information and IMO this is sufficient to build an external webUI appli

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-10 Thread Ananth G
+1 for a UI for Apex. -0 for making it part of the STRAM. - Regarding same port, I was wondering if there will be usage patterns based on firewall rules just based on ports ? This leads us to a situation where we have to trust all users at the same level as the application communication patterns.

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-09 Thread Thomas Weise
strong +1 for adding a UI to Apex. This is actually something that users expect and are accustomed to with similar projects. Thanks for taking the initiative. There are nuances to be discussed, but the overall plan LGTM. To your question, I think this should use the existing web port with a diffe

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-09 Thread Vlad Rozov
-0: stram provides REST API to query runtime information and IMO this is sufficient to build an external webUI application(s). Thank you, Vlad On 6/6/18 11:17, Ambarish Pande wrote: +1 For this feature. It would be really helpfull for users to visualize all this information and the DAG. +1

Re: Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-06 Thread Ambarish Pande
+1 For this feature. It would be really helpfull for users to visualize all this information and the DAG. +1 for ReactJS + MaterialUI A great choice, given its flexibility and performance. I would like to contribute to this effort. On Wed, 6 Jun 2018 at 8:13 PM, Chinmay Kolhatkar wrote: > H

Proposal for UI component in stram

2018-06-06 Thread Chinmay Kolhatkar
Hi Community, I want to propose a feature in apex-core to have a UI component in stram. This is influenced by how basic runtime information is shown on UI by spark. This includes following features: 1. Webpage will be hosted by stram and will be available for user to view in one of the two ways (