Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-17 Thread YuanSheng Wang
to @SHeng "-1 binding The whole topic is actually not a thing determined by the community or the PMC." You are right, I agree with you. so I think we do not need to discuss this topic anymore, all right? It is meaningless. The next step, I think we should move to a new topic: "do we need to cre

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Ming Wen
uld the person who initiated the discussion still be blamed? > > Are you suggesting blaming others or nobody should be blamed? > > 发件人: Ming Wen > 发送时间: 2022年7月13日 17:32 > 收件人: dev@apisix.apache.org > 主题: Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-p

回复: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Yilin Zeng
人: Ming Wen 发送时间: 2022年7月13日 17:32 收件人: dev@apisix.apache.org 主题: Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX > In addition, Sheng's -1 vote has not been, and still is not taken seriously. According to Apache Voting Process[1], "-1 vote

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Ming Wen
keep an eye on it. > > APISIX has done a good job following the voting process strickly, but I am > suprised to see this thing going wild. > > [1] https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html > > Regards, > > Yilin Zeng > > ____________________ > 发件人: Chao

回复: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Yilin Zeng
Regards, Yilin Zeng 发件人: Chao Zhang 发送时间: 2022年7月13日 15:41 收件人: dev@apisix.apache.org 主题: Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX Hi, I just look through the whole context. I think consulting a better place to put this project is not proper h

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread hui li
Thanks for the reminder My intention was to create a subproject of Apache APISIX and should not have mentioned api7 Chao Zhang 于2022年7月13日周三 15:41写道: > Hi, > > I just look through the whole context. I think consulting a better > place to put this project is not proper here. > > If you want to p

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread hui li
Sorry My intention was to start a DISCUSS about 'Create a subproject for Apache APISIX' with the aim of creating a profiling subproject. To add, this project has nothing to do with api7. In that case, wouldn't it be in the ownership of what the PMC or community? So, do I need to send a new DISC

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Chao Zhang
Hi, I just look through the whole context. I think consulting a better place to put this project is not proper here. If you want to put this project to the repo under a commercial company, you can just communicate with people in this company. Rather than sending mail here. Best regards Chao Zhan

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-13 Thread Sheng Wu
Why is my concern being ignored in the whole discussion context? How does this community work? Sheng Wu 吴晟 Twitter, wusheng1108 hui li 于2022年7月13日周三 14:58写道: > > I have a question > > Is the voting mail sent to priv...@apisix.apache.org or > dev@apisix.apache.org? > > YuanSheng Wang 于2022年7月10日

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-12 Thread hui li
I have a question Is the voting mail sent to priv...@apisix.apache.org or dev@apisix.apache.org? YuanSheng Wang 于2022年7月10日周日 22:45写道: > I think we have got a result. > > @yousa, if you're ready, you can submit a "Create an Apache subproject for > .." vote. > > > On Fri, Jul 8, 2022 at 2:53

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-10 Thread YuanSheng Wang
I think we have got a result. @yousa, if you're ready, you can submit a "Create an Apache subproject for .." vote. On Fri, Jul 8, 2022 at 2:53 PM Sheng Wu wrote: > -1 binding > > The whole topic is actually not a thing determined by the community or the > PMC. > This is wrong from an owner

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread Sheng Wu
-1 binding The whole topic is actually not a thing determined by the community or the PMC. This is wrong from an ownership perspective. Sheng Wu 吴晟 Twitter, wusheng1108 shirui zhao 于2022年7月8日周五 14:34写道: > > +1, for sub project of Apache APISIX. It’s a very nice work! > > — > Thanks, > Shirui Zh

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread shirui zhao
+1, very nice work! — Thanks, Shirui Zhao > 2022年7月8日 14:21,Zexuan Luo 写道: > > +1 for creating this project in the apache group as a > sub-project of the Apache APISIX > > Ming Wen 于2022年7月8日周五 14:05写道: >> >> +1 for sub project of Apache APISIX >> >> Thanks, >> Ming Wen, Apache APISIX PMC C

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread shirui zhao
+1, for sub project of Apache APISIX. It’s a very nice work! — Thanks, Shirui Zhao > 2022年7月8日 14:21,Zexuan Luo 写道: > > +1 for creating this project in the apache group as a > sub-project of the Apache APISIX > > Ming Wen 于2022年7月8日周五 14:05写道: >> >> +1 for sub project of Apache APISIX >> >>

[Concerns] Project Neutral Status? [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread Sheng Wu
I think I had mentioned, that this is not a suitable topic in the main list from the foundation perspective. But you still asked, I have to speak out about the concerns about the neutral status of the project PMC. The APISIX should be purely neutral from any vendor, which is one major purpose of

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread Zexuan Luo
+1 for creating this project in the apache group as a sub-project of the Apache APISIX Ming Wen 于2022年7月8日周五 14:05写道: > > +1 for sub project of Apache APISIX > > Thanks, > Ming Wen, Apache APISIX PMC Chair > Twitter: _WenMing > > > hui li 于2022年7月8日周五 11:04写道: > > > Hi, I currently have a new Pr

Re: [DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread Ming Wen
+1 for sub project of Apache APISIX Thanks, Ming Wen, Apache APISIX PMC Chair Twitter: _WenMing hui li 于2022年7月8日周五 11:04写道: > Hi, I currently have a new Profile Toolkit project dedicated to Apache > APISIX in the Summer-OSPP. The project uses eBPF to capture and parse the > lua call stack inf

[DISCUSS] A New Apache APISIX sub-project - A Profile Toolkit For Apache APISIX

2022-07-07 Thread hui li
Hi, I currently have a new Profile Toolkit project dedicated to Apache APISIX in the Summer-OSPP. The project uses eBPF to capture and parse the lua call stack information in Apache APISIX, aggregate it and generate cpu flame maps. I would like to ask if this project is better created in the apach