Re: openstack plugin

Attached. Note that I include a modified version of the plugin.yaml for openstack that Aria uses by default (in the imports dir). The change of interest is in the aria.openstack.datatypes.Server data type. On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 4:03 PM, Tal Liron wrote: > You are allowed

Re: openstack plugin

You are allowed to add extra inputs at the node type, beyond what is defined in the interface type. You just can't do it at the node template. The error you get is odd. If you could share your complete work, perhaps we can run it and assist you. For me, at least, it's impossible to asses the

Re: openstack plugin

I was afraid you were going to say that. I added a generic map as the "server" property. This passes the parse on template load. When I actually then try to use userdata, the install workflow dies in the aria extension registration process, claiming : RuntimeError: Re-definition of yaml-1.1 in

Re: openstack plugin

In TOSCA, properties must have a well-defined schema, and as such it means that the "server" property's datatype must be defined to have the "userdata" field for users to be able to use it through there. This is also true for operation inputs at this time, although AFAIK the spec does in fact

Re: openstack plugin

Rather than opening a potentially misguided PR, let me ask a simple question whos answer may clear things up: I want to use server "userdata" using the Openstack plugin from ARIA. The question is "how can I make that happen?" On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 1:39 AM, Ran Ziv wrote: >

Re: Use & impact of role/host attribute in ARIA

First of all, "role" is an extension and is only used internally. It is indeed not defined by TOSCA and you shouldn't be using it yourself. The reason "role" exists is to avoid hardcoding functionality to type names. Certain normative types play special roles in TOSCA: certain relationships are

Re: Service Composition / Substitution Mapping

"directives" is just a list of strings. Moreover, it seems like a placeholder for something in the future. Also note that "directives" exist only for node templates, not node type, so this means that in order to use substitution we would have to have a node template marked as being abstract. If we

Re: Use & impact of role/host attribute in ARIA

(I'll let Tal take this one :P) On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 2:26 PM, D Jayachandran wrote: > Yes, I can see that Ran. So that was my question , why was role being > added to the types ? > TOSCA spec does not say about a parameter called role. I feel this is not > aligned

RE: Use & impact of role/host attribute in ARIA

Yes, I can see that Ran. So that was my question , why was role being added to the types ? TOSCA spec does not say about a parameter called role. I feel this is not aligned with TOSCA spec. Regards, DJ -Original Message- From: Ran Ziv [mailto:r...@cloudify.co] Sent: Wednesday,

Re: Use & impact of role/host attribute in ARIA

This is where the execution plugin decides whether to run locally or remotely (ssh): https://github.com/apache/incubator-ariatosca/blob/0.1.1/aria/orchestrator/execution_plugin/instantiation.py#L42 This is indeed related to the "host" role definition. Here you can see the assignment of the

Re: Service Composition / Substitution Mapping

On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 6:09 PM, Tal Liron wrote: > > Just like you can specify a specific node template for a requirement, I > believe it can be useful and often necessary to specify a substituted > service template. > ​Even​ if it is needed, the question is how to do that.

Re: openstack plugin

Well then, feel free to create an issue, and either submit the smaller fix, or create a PR which goes beyond this as you say :) On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 6:52 PM, DeWayne Filppi wrote: > Yes, I believe you've got the idea. The original "server" arg is defined > as a

Re: error after adding "userdata" or "user_data" to plugin.yaml

DeWayne, highlighting doesn't work too well with the mailing list - we only see simple text. The error doesn't ring a bell here. On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 8:43 AM, DeWayne Filppi wrote: > I have no idea if its a bug. Just seeing if it looked familiar to anyone. > Thought

RE: Service Composition / Substitution Mapping

Thanks Tal. I agree this needs to taken up with OASIS. Having said that ,there is statement in TOSCA Spec 2.9 " In TOSCA templates, nodes are either: · Concrete: meaning that they have a deployment and/or one or more implementation artifacts that are declared on the “create” operation

Use & impact of role/host attribute in ARIA

Hi, I just noticed the "role" attribute is added for different "capability" and "node" types in ARIA profiles. There is no such role with the TOSCA spec. Why is this been added in the profiles ? What is the use of them ? I faced an issue when I run a local script as part of the Interface