Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Arrow 10.0.0 - RC0

2022-10-22 Thread David Li
Still WIP for me. Verified: - C++, Python, Java, binaries on Ubuntu Linux 18.04/AMD64 - C++, Python, Java on MacOS 12.3/AArch64 * MacOS required Rosetta installed to generate Protobuf sources for Java * I needed https://github.com/apache/arrow/pull/14477 to verify APT packages on Linux * I needed

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to

2022-10-22 Thread Todd Farmer
I can't claim experience migrating to GitHub issues, but I've done some work with Jira APIs and import/export tools. I'm happy to help draft a proposal or proof-of-concept to validate if nobody else expresses interest, or to assist anybody who does. Todd On Sat, Oct 22, 2022 at 12:08 PM Neal Rich

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to

2022-10-22 Thread Neal Richardson
I would guess that mostly could be handled with labels, though that does turn into lots of labels. GitHub also seems to have grown some useful features for this, like Projects [1] and Milestones, and we should look into how to make them work for us. While I agree that those features in the current

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to GitHub Issues

2022-10-22 Thread Andy Grove
We enabled discussions a while back, and it has been ineffective so far. We have only had a few discussions created and we are slow to respond to them, which I think is due to lack of notifications but I could be wrong. On Sat, Oct 22, 2022 at 8:00 AM Ivan Ogasawara wrote: > IMHO I think that it

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to

2022-10-22 Thread Antoine Pitrou
Hi Neal, Le 22/10/2022 à 15:35, Neal Richardson a écrit : Their email says: Infra knows this process change places an increasing burden on PMC members for managing contributors, and makes it harder for people to contribute bug reports. We suggest projects consider using GitHub Issues for

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to GitHub Issues

2022-10-22 Thread Ivan Ogasawara
IMHO I think that it makes total sense to have all in the same platform, for the reasons already mentioned. Question: does it make sense to enable github discussions for questions? On Sat, Oct 22, 2022, 09:55 Andy Grove wrote: > I believe that using GitHub issues has reduced overhead for us in

Re: [DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to GitHub Issues

2022-10-22 Thread Andy Grove
I believe that using GitHub issues has reduced overhead for us in the Rust projects and lowered the barrier for new contributors. As shown in the blog post for the latest DataFusion release alone [1], there were 62 contributors and 31 of them contributed a single PR, so I think that demonstrates th

[DISCUSS] Move issue tracking to GitHub Issues

2022-10-22 Thread Neal Richardson
Hi all, ASF Infra has announced [1] that, due to spam account creation, it will no longer be possible for people to sign themselves up for a Jira account to report issues as of November 6. Instead, the PMC will have to request the creation of Jira accounts. Their email says: > Infra knows this pr

[RUST][DataFusion] Project Update Blog

2022-10-22 Thread Andrew Lamb
We are working on a blog post [1] that highlights the advances made in DataFusion over the last 5 months (a lot!). Any contributions and/or review from the community would be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Andrew [1] https://github.com/apache/arrow-site/pull/254