RE: [Fwd: Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot]

2003-12-19 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> > One boss says = PMC list > > The second "boss" says = Dev list. Legally, there is one boss. Socially, this is a collaboration of peers. In my opinion, Berin is correct that the PMC is responsible for decision-making. And Stephen is also correct that the discussion "should" happen on [EMAIL

Re: Release effort...

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
Another thing I noticed... If the Downloads of repo artifacts are interrupted for some reason, it doesn't understand that, and on next start will not finish it and there will be corrupted artifacts in the local cache. Niclas

Re: Release effort...

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
merlin-server.sh has the positional expansion of "$*" which I think should be "$@". >From man page; The shell treats several parameters specially. These parameters may only be referenced; assignment to them is not allowed. * Expands to the positional parameters, sta

Re: Release effort...

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
Next thing... RUN_CMD="\"$JAVA\" \"-Djava.security.policy=$MERLIN_HOME/bin/security.policy\" \"-Djava.ext.dirs=$MERLIN_HOME/ext\" -jar \"$MERLIN_HOME/bin/lib/merlin-cli-3.2.jar\" \"[EMAIL PROTECTED]"" echo "RUN CMD IS: $RUN_CMD" exec $RUN_CMD does not work on my system. [EMAIL PROTECTED] mer

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Timothy Bennett
Niclas Hedhman wrote: It is not only about "server" + "commandline", there are so much else, as LSD points out, no plugin for IDEA, which for him would be a regression. Is this not a Subversion plug-in for IDEA: http://svnup.tigris.org/ ??

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Timothy Bennett
Niclas Hedhman wrote: Feel free to bring up the issue again, especially when major Linux distros come with it installed by default, the main IDEs have good working implementations and the development community at large feels comfortable with it. Installed the Eclipse plug-in for Subversion toni

Re: Release effort...

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Saturday 20 December 2003 12:47, Niclas Hedhman wrote: > Found one small thing during download... > > "repository", not "reposiory" ;o) > > in the tar/zip filenames Also inside the files. Found it in the "project.xml" file, had the wrong value. Committed already. Niclas

cvs commit: avalon/repository project.xml

2003-12-19 Thread niclas
niclas 2003/12/19 20:50:21 Modified:repository project.xml Log: Wrong ID in project descriptor. Revision ChangesPath 1.8 +1 -1 avalon/repository/project.xml Index: project.xml === RCS fil

Release effort...

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
Found one small thing during download... "repository", not "reposiory" ;o) in the tar/zip filenames Niclas - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
ge of the class named LOADER to LoaderUtils. The merlin update includes the inclusion of the Cygwin script updates. Avalon Repository RC4 http://www.apache.org/~mcconnell/dist/avalon/avalon-repository/ CVS tag: Merlin 20031219 http://www.apache.org/~mcconnell/dist/avalon/merlin/ If no issue

Re: [Fwd: Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot]

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Niclas Hedhman wrote: On Saturday 20 December 2003 10:41, Alex Karasulu wrote: Just wanted to make sure the dev list got this email. Will make sure I post on dev list wrt this conversation. :o) One boss says = PMC list The second "boss" says = Dev list. I just don't know where to turn

Re: avalon template project

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Alex Karasulu wrote: Say Steve what do you think about adding a gencomp or gensvc to the Maven Merlin plugin? It could pull down the needed templates and start from there. What are your thoughts? Actually - I was thinkig about this sort of thing in terms of an Eclispe plugin - but yes - it

*** JIRA - PLEASE CHECK/TEST ***

2003-12-19 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Guys, Apache has set up Jira on nagoya (http://nagoya.apache.org/jira). We are in the process of working with codehaus to migrate all of the ASF projects. We're currently using a test load from codehaus. We have done some preliminary checks, and it appears to be working OK. We have purged the

Re: [Fwd: Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot]

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Saturday 20 December 2003 10:41, Alex Karasulu wrote: > Just wanted to make sure the dev list got this email. > Will make sure I post on dev list wrt this conversation. :o) One boss says = PMC list The second "boss" says = Dev list. I just don't know where to turn... Cheers, Niclas ---

Re: avalon template project

2003-12-19 Thread Alex Karasulu
Say Steve what do you think about adding a gencomp or gensvc to the Maven Merlin plugin? It could pull down the needed templates and start from there. What are your thoughts? Alex > > From: Stephen McConnell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Date: 2003/12/19 Fri PM 09:18:58 EST > To: Avalon Dev <[EMAIL

[Fwd: Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot]

2003-12-19 Thread Alex Karasulu
Just wanted to make sure the dev list got this email. Will make sure I post on dev list wrt this conversation. > >>My recent exposure to ClearCase also increases my fear that it is an > >>over-engineered product, but I may be utterly wrong. I like the fact that 4 > >>commands does my daily job,

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Saturday 20 December 2003 10:27, Alex Karasulu wrote: > If Peter and Niclas totally oppose the idea of a sandbox > being based on SVN then its enough to avoid it for now. As I have said repeatedly, "At the moment." I feel we don't need to be guineapigs. Before saying "this so much better, or

Re: RE: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Alex Karasulu
Guys, Excuse me for processing emails from least recent to most. I just got throught Niclas' total rejection. And I must say we have as Noel says made a complete about face. It rubbed us completely wrong and we spat at Noel for even recommending it. Poor guy he was only trying to help us and w

avalon template project

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
I have just imported a new subproject title "template" into the Avalon Sandbox. The project is simply a template for a new project that incorporates the maven scripts and directory layout for a clean api/impl seperated project together with project level build and site generation targets. To creat

cvs commit: avalon-sandbox/template project.xml

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 18:11:55 Modified:template/impl/conf sample.block template project.xml Log: use template as the group name Revision ChangesPath 1.2 +2 -2 avalon-sandbox/template/impl/conf/sample.block Index: sample.block ==

cvs commit: avalon-sandbox/template maven.xml

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 17:57:10 Modified:template maven.xml Log: Add avalon:build as a prereq to site. Revision ChangesPath 1.2 +1 -1 avalon-sandbox/template/maven.xml Index: maven.xml === RC

cvs commit: avalon-sandbox/kernel/cli .cvsignore maven.xml merlin.properties project.properties project.xml

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 17:41:35 Removed: kernel .cvsignore maven.xml project.xml kernel/cli .cvsignore maven.xml merlin.properties project.properties project.xml Log: Removal of cruft.

cvs commit: avalon-sandbox/kernel/unit/src/test/org/apache/avalon/merlin/unit/test MerlinTestCaseTest.java

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 17:39:45 Removed: kernel/api .cvsignore maven.xml project.xml kernel/api/src/java/org/apache/avalon/merlin Kernel.java KernelController.java KernelCriteria.java KernelException.java KernelRuntimeException.

cvs commit: avalon-sandbox/template - Imported sources

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 17:05:59 Log: A sample project. Status: Vendor Tag: MCCONNELL Release Tags: INITIAL_SUBMISSION N avalon-sandbox/template/LICENSE.txt N avalon-sandbox/template/master.xml N avalon-sandbox/template/maven.xml N avalon-sandbox/template/project.prope

cvs commit: avalon/merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 16:16:00 Modified:merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh Log: Properly correct merlinx command line parmeters. Revision ChangesPath 1.8 +3 -3 avalon/merlin/platform/src/bin/merlinx.bat Index: merlinx.bat ==

cvs commit: avalon/merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 15:40:04 Modified:merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh Log: Corredct merlinx command line parmeters. Revision ChangesPath 1.7 +1 -8 avalon/merlin/platform/src/bin/merlinx.bat Index: merlinx.bat ==

Re: Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
S tag: Merlin 20031219 http://www.apache.org/~mcconnell/dist/avalon/merlin/ If no issues are raised over the weekend I'll launch a new vote on Monday. Cheers, Steve. -- Stephen J. McConnell mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] || | Magic

Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
class named LOADER to LoaderUtils. The merlin update includes the inclusion of the Cygwin script updates. Avalon Repository RC4 http://www.apache.org/~mcconnell/dist/avalon/avalon-repository/ CVS tag: Merlin 20031219 http://www.apache.org/~mcconnell/dist/avalon/merlin/ If no issues are raised

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Timothy Bennett
Noel J. Bergman wrote: We have real projects using Subversion already. We will almost certainly be migrating in 2004. The option on the table today was to move part of Avalon into Subversion, not all of it. FWIW, I've got a Subversion server set up on my Win2k box at work. I use TortoiseSVN fr

RE: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Eric Pugh
Are all the updated tutorials for this new RC in CVS already? Is there any specific tutorial/unit test to look at to better understand the new embedding stuff that you would recommend? Assuming that this goes forward ;-), then this Embeddable Merlin is all that Turbine 2.4 is waiting for then. C

RE: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Niclas Hedhman wrote: > Peter Royal is negative to subversion. > Right now, I am so negative that if it goes through at this point in time, > I'll probably volunteerly leave Avalon as quickly as I came in. Why? >From what I saw of your comments, you had more questions than knowledge. You praised

Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Jörg: Have just applied the versions of the scripts you posted to me back on the 12th (plus updates on cli version, updates to sync with repo system properties and removal of merlin.home system property). Can you please confirm that these all run ok in you environment? Cheers, Steve. Jörg Sc

cvs commit: avalon/merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh merlin-server.sh merlin.sh

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 09:41:22 Modified:merlin/platform/src/bin merlin-server.sh merlin.sh Added: merlin/platform/src/bin merlinx.bat merlinx.sh Log: Sync. with repo RC4 and include Cygen scripts. Revision ChangesPath 1.6 +9 -14 avalon/merlin/platform/src/

Re: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Leo Simons wrote: Stephen McConnell wrote: Leo Simons wrote: Stephen McConnell wrote: This is a vote for the release of the following products: are these to be considered *final* releases? Yes. okay. And this vote is a vote by all of the community which will be follow-upped by a pmc v

Re: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Leo Simons
Stephen McConnell wrote: Leo Simons wrote: Stephen McConnell wrote: This is a vote for the release of the following products: are these to be considered *final* releases? Yes. okay. And this vote is a vote by all of the community which will be follow-upped by a pmc vote to make things binding, r

Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot

2003-12-19 Thread Leo Simons
Berin Loritsch wrote: Any oppinions? I would prefer to wait until * svn is release 1.0 or later; * IntelliJ IDEA has good support; before we move anything over in daily use (I'm game for experimentation though). I just love the cvs integration in the idea 4.0 EAP. - LSD --

Re: More Release()

2003-12-19 Thread Leo Simons
Stephen McConnell wrote: Leo Simons wrote: It's interesting to see what happens if you remove the support/requirement for release semantics. You can still implement singleton semantics, per-thread semantics, per-lookup semantics, fixed-number-of-multithreaded-object semantics, and the like. Whic

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Berin Loritsch
Niclas Hedhman wrote: Shall we have a vote? Shall the vote be on dev or pmc?? Give it a break ;o) Seriously, Peter Royal is negative to subversion. Right now, I am so negative that if it goes through at this point in time, I'll probably volunteerly leave Avalon as quickly as I came in. I think

Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot

2003-12-19 Thread Berin Loritsch
Niclas Hedhman wrote: My recent exposure to ClearCase also increases my fear that it is an over-engineered product, but I may be utterly wrong. I like the fact that 4 commands does my daily job, not the 15 or so commands in CC. I agree with your assessment of ClearCase. However, I can say that

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
Shall we have a vote? Shall the vote be on dev or pmc?? Give it a break ;o) Seriously, Peter Royal is negative to subversion. Right now, I am so negative that if it goes through at this point in time, I'll probably volunteerly leave Avalon as quickly as I came in. I think some other "moderates

Re: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Hamilton Verissimo de Oliveira (Engenharia - SPO)
-Mensagem original- De: Stephen McConnell [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Looks like a few people want to see the LOADER renamed to something else > - and given that we need to update and validate the scripts to take into > account the the Cygwin fixes (which I missed) - I figured another RC

cvs commit: avalon/repository/util/src/java/org/apache/avalon/repository/util LoaderUtils.java LOADER.java

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 08:46:15 Modified:repository project.xml repository/impl/src/java/org/apache/avalon/repository/impl DefaultCacheManager.java DefaultRepository.java repository/main/src/java/org/apache/avalon/repository/main

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Berin Loritsch wrote: Stephen McConnell wrote: Bacause this is a technical subject - it does not belong on the PMC list - it belongs here. Actually, it is something the PMC is responsible for. Technical matters that the PMC has no say in are the kind that affect the CODE. Configuration Ma

Re: [PMC:Proposal] Subversion Pilot

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Saturday 20 December 2003 01:18, Hamilton Verissimo de Oliveira (Engenharia - SPO) wrote: > De: Niclas Hedhman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > convince me to move away from CVS at this point in time. > > Sure. Or you just don't want to learn different commands arguments ;-) There is a lot of sma

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Berin Loritsch
Stephen McConnell wrote: Bacause this is a technical subject - it does not belong on the PMC list - it belongs here. Actually, it is something the PMC is responsible for. Technical matters that the PMC has no say in are the kind that affect the CODE. Configuration Management concerns such as JI

Re: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Niclas Hedhman wrote: I don't know how long I can delay my vote; On Thursday 18 December 2003 10:30, Stephen McConnell wrote: 1. Avalon Utilities 1.0 +1 2. Avalon Repository 1.2 +0 (not played with it yet) Looks like a few people want to see the LOADER renamed to something

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Noel J. Bergman wrote: Berin Loritsch wrote: Noel J. Bergman wrote: We have projects using Subversion now. Sometime in 2004, there will be a switch over from CVS. If people want, we can set up avalon/[sandbox/]avalon-net. This is a vote we should have with the PMC. BTW, shou

Re: Apache Logging Services top level project

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Friday 19 December 2003 04:02, Berin Loritsch wrote: > I believe we should merely migrate toward what is produced by the logging > TLP. And they need more IoC ;o) , and ways to block the direct access... Niclas - To unsubsc

Re: Repository Manager

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Thursday 18 December 2003 22:35, Yannick Menager wrote: > Not yet... that is on the TODO list ;-) Right now it can only be run > standalone. > > But I'm planning on adding an adaptor to integrate it within IDEA and > Eclipse I need to take a sharp look at this... :o) If I can wrap the "remote

Re: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Niclas Hedhman
I don't know how long I can delay my vote; On Thursday 18 December 2003 10:30, Stephen McConnell wrote: > 1. Avalon Utilities 1.0 +1 > 2. Avalon Repository 1.2 +0 (not played with it yet) > 3. Avalon Meta 1.3 +1 > 4. Avalon Merlin 3.2 +0 (not played enough with it yet) Niclas

RE: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Berin Loritsch wrote: > Noel J. Bergman wrote: > > We have projects using Subversion now. Sometime in 2004, there > > will be a switch over from CVS. If people want, we can set up > > avalon/[sandbox/]avalon-net. > This is a vote we should have with the PMC. BTW, should we CC: > the developer's

cvs commit: avalon/merlin/platform/src/repository/merlin/xmls kernel.xml

2003-12-19 Thread mcconnell
mcconnell2003/12/19 08:08:57 Removed: merlin/platform/src/repository/merlin/jnlps merlin.jnlp merlin/platform/src/repository/merlin/xmls kernel.xml Log: Remove content that is out-of-date and not included in the dist. --

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Stephen McConnell
Berin Loritsch wrote: Noel J. Bergman wrote: Berin Loritsch wrote: Yes, I know the next update will remove an empty folder from your working copy, but stills ugly. Is there any plan to move to subversion? The last time we talked about subversion ... We have projects using Subversion now

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Berin Loritsch
Noel J. Bergman wrote: Berin Loritsch wrote: Yes, I know the next update will remove an empty folder from your working copy, but stills ugly. Is there any plan to move to subversion? The last time we talked about subversion ... We have projects using Subversion now. Sometime in 2004, there

Re: How are you handling CVS/folders?

2003-12-19 Thread Hamilton Verissimo de Oliveira (Engenharia - SPO)
-Mensagem original- De: Noel J. Bergman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > We have projects using Subversion now. Sometime in 2004, there will be a > switch over from CVS. If people want, we can set up > avalon/[sandbox/]avalon-net. Why not? That would be cool and a primary test that won't aff

RES: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Hamilton Verissimo de Oliveira (Engenharia - SPO)
>>> 2. Avalon Repository 1.2 >> >>I looked in the site for more info about it, didn't find anything. >> > http://avalon.apache.org/repository Doh!! hammett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands,

RE: [VOTE] Merlin, Meta, Repository, Utilities - release

2003-12-19 Thread Jörg Schaible
Stephen McConnell wrote on Thursday, December 18, 2003 11:32 PM: > Jörg Schaible wrote: >> This package does not contain the patches to the scripts starting >> merlin and have following errors: >> >> - Merlin cannot be started in Cygwin >> - No parameter containing spaces can be defined in any OS

Arch (was: How are you handling CVS/folders?)

2003-12-19 Thread Alexis Agahi
On Thursday 18 December 2003 20:02, Hamilton Verissimo de Oliveira (Engenharia - SPO) wrote: > The worst thing in the CVS is keeping folders. It's all right if a project > wouldn't change, but I have never seen it happens. > > This weekend I'll change some things in the avalon# and don't like to g