Re: [DISCUSS] restrict JDK test matrix

2022-10-07 Thread Alessandro Solimando
Hello everyone, I have prepared a PR, if anyone feels like taking a look at it, it's here: https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/2928 If there are no feedback/objections I will merge it early next week. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts around this! Best regards, Alessandro On Tue, 4 Oct

Re: [DISCUSS] restrict JDK test matrix

2022-10-04 Thread Alessandro Solimando
Julian, Stamatis, thanks for your input! Since it seems that there is consensus around the topic, I have logged CALCITE-5306 . As soon as I have a PR ready, I will reply to this thread too, in order to collect opinions and feedback. Best

Re: [DISCUSS] restrict JDK test matrix

2022-10-04 Thread Stamatis Zampetakis
Hello, It is not recommended to use EOL software so dropping those JDK versions from the test matrix makes sense. Anyways it wouldn't be surprising if Jenkins, Travis, Github Actions, etc., remove those EOL versions as well at some point. Best, Stamatis On Mon, Oct 3, 2022 at 3:15 PM Julian

Re: [DISCUSS] restrict JDK test matrix

2022-10-03 Thread Julian Hyde
It makes sense to only test on 8, 11, 17 and the latest. Testing on other versions is going to waste time checking on false negatives. I don’t remember whether there’s ever been an issue on, say, 15, that wasn’t also present in 11 or 17. Maybe it’s a distinction without a difference, but I

[DISCUSS] restrict JDK test matrix

2022-10-03 Thread Alessandro Solimando
Hello everyone, I was checking a build failure related to JDK15 and I wanted to try it locally, however I can't do it via sdkman (a "multi-platform software manager") as JDK is not anymore available. This is not