On Sun, Nov 9, 2008 at 1:14 AM, Russel Winder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: <snip/> > > For a couple of my projects, Codehaus is the host so the central > mainline is a Subversion repository. However most work is done using > Bazaar or Git since people do not need an account to be able to work > using a full VCS. Using a DVCS makes working on a FOSS project truly > open. > <snap/>
Yes, there are many advantages, productivity improvements etc. But lets not tout openness. There are certain things to keep in mind. We are truly open in the sense that anyone can access the code and propose changes. We are not truly open in the sense that we make a concerted effort to vet any contributions and make sure they are encumbrance-free. We require folks demonstrate merit first. We require people to understand and agree to certain terms before they make significant contributions. In essence, we require contributors to be aware there are certain requirements that enable corporations, large and small, and individuals alike to pick up code developed here and use it in their products or work with a reasonable degree of assuredness. Lets call this requirement the state of awareness. Consider there is a DVCS master (say, a focal point for official releases) that pulls from N levels of a tree (the topology may be very different, but for the sake of this discussion, a tree may be a reasonable starting point). It is then, not sufficient to have this state of awareness for some levels n where n < N. It has to exist from the root to each leaf. Furthermore, it has to be transparent, trivial to ascertain, auditable and governable (governance is a slightly emphatic term). Any practice that dilutes the above value proposition that our software has for many of our users, be it a true or truthy (AKA popular perception) dilution, is not acceptable. This is all possible with DVCS. It is possible to make sure that all code is pulled in with this state of awareness, all parties involved understand and subscribe to the thinking that is behind our license etc. But therein you already have a restriction. And within those bounds, we are already truly open. -Rahul --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
