Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-17 Thread Shazron
We keep seeing this failed Media test on Android 4.4: https://github.com/apache/cordova-plugin-media/pull/166 I'm not sure of the state of our Android support, especially 4.4. Does anyone have any pointers? Thanks

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-17 Thread Darryl Pogue
Speaking as a Cordova user, Android 4.4 still accounts for an agonizing 10.3% of devices (as of May 2018)[1] and our company's apps are still required to support it. I can't speak to the media plugin, since I've never used it, but I can confirm that the latest cordova-android still supports 4.4 al

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-18 Thread julio cesar sanchez
Yeah, we official dropped support of SDK < 19 on cordova-android 7.x.x, so we still support Android 4.4. I think we can merge that and create a new issue for Android 4.4 tests, media tests has been broken for a long time, so hard to tell if that failure is related to the changes or not, but at lea

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-18 Thread Ken Naito
I have investigated the test failure for Android 4.4. For cordova-plugin-media, the cause of the failure may be the SSL handshake. The MediaPlayer in Android 4.4 can not connect to a modern SSL server. For example: https://cordova.apache.org/downloads/BlueZedEx.mp3 https://cordova-develop.g

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-18 Thread Shazron
Thanks Ken! I think we should go for the simpler option, and log this as a new issue that is known and out of our control. Android 4.4 (even though 10% of the market) should not be a priority for us. On Tue, Jun 19, 2018 at 12:30 PM Ken Naito wrote: > > I have investigated the test failure for A

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-19 Thread Ken Naito
Hi Shazron, Thanks for the advice! I sent a new commit of PR, which removes some tests for Android 4.4. Ken Naito. On 2018/06/19 13:35, Shazron wrote: Thanks Ken! I think we should go for the simpler option, and log this as a new issue that is known and out of our control. Android 4.4 (even t

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-19 Thread julio cesar sanchez
Why don't we just use http instead of https? shouldn't that fix the problems too? or https is required in other platforms? 2018-06-19 11:32 GMT+02:00 Ken Naito : > Hi Shazron, > > Thanks for the advice! > I sent a new commit of PR, which removes some tests for Android 4.4. > > Ken Naito. > > On 2

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-19 Thread Shazron
Using http might fix the test, for sure - but I think we should move on to testing https only, as the new normal. Although this is through one major browser vendor (which dwarfs all others at 60% market share) -- the coming https-pocalypse later this year (see https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/08/chr

Re: Android 4.4 support?

2018-06-19 Thread Shazron
"We should consider KitKat 'abandoned'" w.r.t. the media plugin, not Cordova... On Tue, Jun 19, 2018 at 11:47 PM Shazron wrote: > Using http might fix the test, for sure - but I think we should move on to > testing https only, as the new normal. > > Although this is through one major browser ven

[PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Bryan Ellis
as security updates for KitKat, there are none. The last release of KitKat was 5 years and 2 months ago. I think it is safe to say that deprecating Android 4.4 support is a good move. Lastly, IF the votes are more in favor of dropping, the next question would be what version should be supported at

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
for Android 4.4 is only at 2.6%*. Additionally, there is a report of *128 vulnerabilities in Android 4.4.4*. As far as security updates for KitKat, there are none. The last release of KitKat was 5 years and 2 months ago. I think it is safe to say that deprecating Android 4.4 support is a good move. Las

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread julio cesar sanchez
that the *market share for Android > 4.4 > > is only at 2.6%*. > > > > Additionally, there is a report of *128 vulnerabilities in Android > 4.4.4*. > > As far as security updates for KitKat, there are none. The last release > of > > KitKat was 5 years and 2 m

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
eport of *128 vulnerabilities in Android 4.4.4*. As far as security updates for KitKat, there are none. The last release of KitKat was 5 years and 2 months ago. I think it is safe to say that deprecating Android 4.4 support is a good move. Lastly, IF the votes are more in favor of dropping, the next questi

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Chris Brody
+1 to drop Android 4.4 support > Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? > > Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I leaned > over to 5.1. So low usage was my primary reasoning for my +1. +1 to drop 5.0 and +1 on the reasoning h

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Jesse
+1 to drop everything before 5.1 > On Jan 28, 2020, at 7:53 AM, Chris Brody wrote: > > +1 to drop Android 4.4 support > >> Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? >> >> Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Bryan Ellis
ody wrote: > +1 to drop Android 4.4 support > > > Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? > > > > Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I leaned > > over to 5.1. So low usage was my primary reasoning for my +1. &g

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread julio cesar sanchez
rk on Android 4.4. These are changes that would possibly come. > We just have to think about the "updatable webview" when that time comes. > > > On Wed, Jan 29, 2020 at 12:53 AM Chris Brody > wrote: > > > +1 to drop Android 4.4 support > > > > > Do we

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Gearoid M
; Lastly, if we started to convert the browser code to ES6, for example, it > > will not work on Android 4.4. These are changes that would possibly come. > > We just have to think about the "updatable webview" when that time comes. > > > > > > On Wed, Jan 29, 202

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
or example, it will not work on Android 4.4. These are changes that would possibly come. We just have to think about the "updatable webview" when that time comes. On Wed, Jan 29, 2020 at 12:53 AM Chris Brody wrote: +1 to drop Android 4.4 support Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-29 Thread Chris Brody
wn risk. This value could be set in config.xml. > >> > >> What we would say could be along the lines of, it might work with 5.0 but > >> we officially support is 5.1. > >> > >> Lastly, if we started to convert the browser code to ES6, for example, it >