Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-04 Thread Chetan Mehrotra
Hi, <> In Apache Jackrabbit Oak [1] we have inbuilt support for OSGi based deployments. To reuse the logic for non OSGi env I was investigating [2] PojoSR [3] and it looks pretty useful and most of the stuff works out of the box without requiring any change. Wanted to check if there were any tho

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-04 Thread Clement Escoffier
Hi, I’m using PojoSR regularly (especially to simplify OSGi testing). I would be also in favor on donating pojoSR to Felix. But Karl have to take the decision. Clement On 5 mars 2014, at 05:46, Chetan Mehrotra wrote: > Hi, > > < to both group sending it to both groups>> > > In Apache Jackr

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Karl Pauls
Hi Chetan, im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - provided you (or somebody else) is willing to do the legwork. I guess we'll have to funnel it through the incubator ip clearance, rename the packages, and cut a release. If somebody volunteers to drive this then lets do it (and yes, I'

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread David Bosschaert
I also think that moving PojoSR to Felix would be a great idea! Cheers, David On 5 March 2014 12:43, Karl Pauls wrote: > Hi Chetan, > > im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - provided you (or > somebody else) is willing to do the legwork. I guess we'll have to funnel > it through t

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Guillaume Nodet
2014-03-05 13:43 GMT+01:00 Karl Pauls : > Hi Chetan, > > im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - provided you (or > somebody else) is willing to do the legwork. I guess we'll have to funnel > it through the incubator ip clearance, rename the packages, and cut a > release. If somebody v

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Marcel Offermans
On 05 Mar 2014, at 14:55 pm, Guillaume Nodet wrote: > 2014-03-05 13:43 GMT+01:00 Karl Pauls : > * we need a formal agreement from the contributors (karlpauls and AngelovdS > from the pojosr commit log) to give copyright to the ASF (a CLA would do it > afaik) For the record, Angelo van der Sijpt

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Karl Pauls
On Wed, Mar 5, 2014 at 2:55 PM, Guillaume Nodet wrote: I'm willing to help too if needed.I don't think we can use a software > grant, unless the code is owned by an actual entity (is that the case ?). > * we need a formal agreement from the contributors (karlpauls and > AngelovdS > from the

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Karl Pauls
On Wed, Mar 5, 2014 at 3:11 PM, Marcel Offermans < marcel.offerm...@luminis.eu> wrote: > On 05 Mar 2014, at 14:55 pm, Guillaume Nodet wrote: > > > 2014-03-05 13:43 GMT+01:00 Karl Pauls : > > * we need a formal agreement from the contributors (karlpauls and > AngelovdS > > from the pojosr commit

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Chetan Mehrotra
On Wed, Mar 5, 2014 at 6:13 PM, Karl Pauls wrote: > im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - provided you (or > somebody else) is willing to do the legwork. I guess we'll have to funnel it > through the incubator ip clearance, rename the packages, and cut a release. > If somebody volunt

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Guillaume Nodet
I've raise the legal question at https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LEGAL-194 to make sure we don't miss anything. In the mean time, I'll start a formal vote to accept the donation. 2014-03-05 13:43 GMT+01:00 Karl Pauls : > Hi Chetan, > > im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - p

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-05 Thread Peter Kriens
Great name!!! Wonderful idea, it is still one of the least recognized jewels in the toolbox to move to OSGi. Kind regards, Peter Kriens On 5 mrt. 2014, at 13:43, Karl Pauls wrote: > Hi Chetan, > > im more than willing to have PojoSR move to Felix - provided you (or > somebody else)

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-06 Thread Raymond Auge
Sorry for my ignorance, but I have to ask! Can PojoSR be used 'within' osgi runtime as a peer to DS, Blueprint? I had previously assumed no, but a conversation with a colleague has me doubting that. - Ray On Mar 6, 2014 2:52 AM, "Peter Kriens" wrote: > Great name!!! > > Wonderful idea, it is s

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-06 Thread David Bosschaert
Hi Ray, PojoSR is not services injection framework, it's a container much like an OSGi Framework with the classloading bits left out ;) You should be able to run DS/Blueprint on top of it, but the pure modularity on the classloading level is gone. It can be quite useful for people who like to use

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-06 Thread Marcel Offermans
On 06 Mar 2014, at 14:58 , David Bosschaert wrote: > It can be quite useful for people who like to use OSGi Services or > migrate to OSGi for other reasons, but don't want to handle the > modularity on the classloader level just yet. Other applications are to deploy OSGi bundles to environments

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-06 Thread Raymond Auge
Great! All this means I'm not crazy! ;) Sincerely, - Ray On Thu, Mar 6, 2014 at 9:03 AM, Marcel Offermans < marcel.offerm...@luminis.nl> wrote: > On 06 Mar 2014, at 14:58 , David Bosschaert > wrote: > > > It can be quite useful for people who like to use OSGi Services or > > migrate to OSGi f

Re: Any plans to make PojoSR part of Apache Felix

2014-03-06 Thread Guillaume Nodet
I've started the IP clearance process, so the form should appear in http://incubator.apache.org/ip-clearance/index.html soon. Fwiw, I won't be available next week, so I'll resume the work after that. Guillaume 2014-03-05 15:47 GMT+01:00 Guillaume Nodet : > I've raise the legal question at > htt