Re: Proposal: Felix Messaging Service

2010-01-08 Thread geert
> While I think the EventAdmin maps well to JMS for distribution of events, > I'm not sure that JMS maps well onto the EventAdmin. That was exactly my conclusion after using LightSabre. I'm missing stuff like transactions in the EventAdmin. > We have a similar need > to integrate JMS into an OSGi

RE: Proposal: Felix Messaging Service

2010-01-07 Thread Craig Phillips
[mailto:gerrywo...@gmail.com] Sent: Thu 1/7/2010 5:52 PM To: dev@felix.apache.org Subject: Re: Proposal: Felix Messaging Service While I think the EventAdmin maps well to JMS for distribution of events, I'm not sure that JMS maps well onto the EventAdmin. We have a similar need to integr

Re: Proposal: Felix Messaging Service

2010-01-07 Thread Gerry Woods
While I think the EventAdmin maps well to JMS for distribution of events, I'm not sure that JMS maps well onto the EventAdmin. We have a similar need to integrate JMS into an OSGi environment. The overriding problem from my point of view is not the lack of an API, but the inherent difficulty of i

Re: Proposal: Felix Messaging Service

2010-01-07 Thread Richard S. Hall
Are you aware of: http://fusesource.com/wiki/display/LIGHTSABRE/Home ? Not exactly the same, but related. I am not familiar enough with JMS to say whether or not a new API is needed or if the EventAdmin API could be commandeered for this purpose. I do think there is potential, but let's s

Proposal: Felix Messaging Service

2010-01-07 Thread Geert Schuring
Hey all, I'm using Felix in a security software integration environment, and it supprised me that I couldn't find a messaging service that would handle JMS messaging for me. Did I miss something? If not, I would like to develop and contribute the "Felix Messaging Service". I have an API bundle