Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-31 Thread Matt Hogstrom
Having consistency is definitely in ours and Maven's best interest. We (us and the Maven guys) need to examine how people manage their versions. Derby is clearly a case where 4 elements is standard. I also agree with David that more dots isn't necessarily good but I've also noticed on the user

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-31 Thread John Sisson
cc PM Subject Re: Repository version precedence

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-31 Thread ian . d . stewart
Re: Repository version precedence Please respond to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-30 Thread John Sisson
Joe Bohn wrote: Am I the only one concerned about this? I am also concerned, just been a bit busy to respond. See comments inline below. I think this is an important issue for our users. They won't have the luxury to wait for a completely new Geronimo image to fix a problem with an embedde

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-30 Thread Joe Bohn
David, I understand your point about potential confusion if we extend the maven capabilities. However, I have to wonder how many of our users are familiar with maven and if this is important to them. If we are to stay closely aligned with Maven, then I agree with you that need to pursue som

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-30 Thread David Jencks
On May 30, 2006, at 10:49 AM, Joe Bohn wrote: Am I the only one concerned about this? I think this is an important issue for our users. They won't have the luxury to wait for a completely new Geronimo image to fix a problem with an embedded component. They will also face these issues w

Re: Repository version precedence

2006-05-30 Thread Joe Bohn
Am I the only one concerned about this? I think this is an important issue for our users. They won't have the luxury to wait for a completely new Geronimo image to fix a problem with an embedded component. They will also face these issues with their own versioned application modules. I woul

Repository version precedence

2006-05-26 Thread Joe Bohn
I'm trying to get my head around the way that we make a version selection when multiple versions of a package are available. This will be important as users need to include different versions of packages beyond what geronimo bundles or if they need to override a package with a local version.