Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jeff Genender
That was my understanding as well. I really think we need the ability to allow folks to set a CLASSPATH without the need to rebuild a config. What do you think? Jeff Dain Sundstrom wrote: Geronimo only reads compiled configurations so if you want to change it you need to rebuild the config

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Dain Sundstrom
Geronimo only reads compiled configurations so if you want to change it you need to rebuild the configuration. -dain On Jul 11, 2005, at 8:08 AM, Jeff Genender wrote: Cool. Do I need to build an assembly though? (Sorry for the repost) Dain Sundstrom wrote: Jars are loaded in the order th

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jeff Genender
Cool. Do I need to build an assembly though? (Sorry for the repost) Dain Sundstrom wrote: Jars are loaded in the order they appear in the xml file. -dain On Jul 11, 2005, at 8:02 AM, Jeff Genender wrote: Can I set the order of which jars will get loaded first? Aaron Mulder wrote: Most

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Dain Sundstrom
Jars are loaded in the order they appear in the xml file. -dain On Jul 11, 2005, at 8:02 AM, Jeff Genender wrote: Can I set the order of which jars will get loaded first? Aaron Mulder wrote: Most often it seems the CLASSPATH is used to add JDBC drivers or common 3rd party libraries. W

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jeff Genender
So will I need to rebuild an assembly when I add a jar ...and in the order I need the jar to be accessed? Jacek Laskowski wrote: Jeff Genender wrote: This is common. Well, it's common on other platforms, but quite contrary to the way Geronimo handles jars. If a configuration needs jars th

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jeff Genender
Can I set the order of which jars will get loaded first? Aaron Mulder wrote: Most often it seems the CLASSPATH is used to add JDBC drivers or common 3rd party libraries. We have special facilities for that in Geronimo, so I don't see that being able to set the CLASSPATH is all that valuable.

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Dain Sundstrom
You don't need to specify a full class path since the server and deployer jars contain a manifest class path. The following commands are equivalent: $ java -jar bin/server.jar $ java -classpath bin/server.jar org.apache.geronimo.system.main.Daemon -dain On Jul 11, 2005, at 5:18 AM, [EMAIL

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jacek Laskowski
Jeff Genender wrote: This is common. Well, it's common on other platforms, but quite contrary to the way Geronimo handles jars. If a configuration needs jars they should be its own dependencies specified in a plan. Jeff Jacek

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jacek Laskowski
Aaron Mulder wrote: Most often it seems the CLASSPATH is used to add JDBC drivers or common 3rd party libraries. We have special facilities for that in Geronimo, so I don't see that being able to set the CLASSPATH is all that valuable. Exactly. That was the reason why I was asking. Unless I

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Aaron Mulder
Most often it seems the CLASSPATH is used to add JDBC drivers or common 3rd party libraries. We have special facilities for that in Geronimo, so I don't see that being able to set the CLASSPATH is all that valuable. Aaron On Mon, 11 Jul 2005 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I am working on

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jeff Genender
Jacek Laskowski wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I am working on the startup scripts for Geronimo and was wondering whether people can see a requirement now or in the future where users would want to be able to specify their own classpath when executing the startup script (e.g. in the CLASSPA

Re: startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread Jacek Laskowski
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I am working on the startup scripts for Geronimo and was wondering whether people can see a requirement now or in the future where users would want to be able to specify their own classpath when executing the startup script (e.g. in the CLASSPATH env var) and have that

startup scripts for Geronimo - will users want to prepend their own classpath?

2005-07-11 Thread sissonj
I am working on the startup scripts for Geronimo and was wondering whether people can see a requirement now or in the future where users would want to be able to specify their own classpath when executing the startup script (e.g. in the CLASSPATH env var) and have that appended to the server's