Re: Thoughts on KARAF-1718

2012-08-19 Thread Andreas Pieber
+1 for 3.0.0. For a start I like it as it is right now :-) Kind regards, Andreas On Sat, Aug 18, 2012 at 7:01 PM, Achim Nierbeck wrote: > +1, since we already had and still have so much un-discussed changes > in the past > > 2012/8/17 Jean-Baptiste Onofré : >> +1, we should be able to make

Re: [DISCUSSION] OSGi core version in Karaf version

2012-08-19 Thread Łukasz Dywicki
We spent one year before releasing 3.x. With this velocity we'll support OSGi 5 in same time as Java will support Jigsaw. IMHO Karaf 4 is too far to plan anything in it, especially that Equinox and Felix will be OSGi 5 compatible in more or less half year, I guess. Best regards, Lukasz Wiadomo

Re: WebConsole versioning

2012-08-19 Thread Łukasz Dywicki
Please keep in mind that Cellar is more specific to Karaf than Web Console is. People can run Web Console on single node, for development purposes and so on. I won't say that Cellar is only for Karaf, but it's mostly used with Karaf. Going further Karaf can be one from platforms supported by Web

Re: [DISCUSSION] OSGi core version in Karaf version

2012-08-19 Thread Andreas Pieber
IMHO we don't need to include the same amount of features for 4.0 as we did for 3.0 and I neither see any problem releasing Karaf 4 in 6-10 month... Kind regards, Andreas On Sun, Aug 19, 2012 at 1:01 PM, Łukasz Dywicki wrote: > We spent one year before releasing 3.x. With this velocity we'll sup

Re: [DISCUSSION] OSGi core version in Karaf version

2012-08-19 Thread Scott England-Sullivan
All, As someone who has to help organizations migrate and define adoption plans I much prefer the plan outlined by Andreas. Creating a break in backwards compatibility in a minor release causes a loss of faith in enterprise organizations. That faith is hard to rebuild later on without a compell

Re: [DISCUSSION] OSGi core version in Karaf version

2012-08-19 Thread Freeman Fang
+1 for Andreas's first plan. Freeman - Freeman Fang FuseSource Email:ff...@fusesource.com Web: fusesource.com Twitter: freemanfang Blog: http://freemanfang.blogspot.com http://blog.sina.com.cn/u/1473905042 weibo: http://weibo.com/u/1473905042 On 2012-8-18, at 下午1:19, Andreas Pieber w