+1 to put in the ref guide; well put Walter.
~ David Smiley
Apache Lucene/Solr Search Developer
http://www.linkedin.com/in/davidwsmiley
On Wed, Mar 27, 2019 at 10:27 AM Walter Underwood
wrote:
> I think it is appropriate to have the table in the reference guide. Yes,
> the guide is versioned,
> On Mar 27, 2019, at 9:03 AM, Erick Erickson wrote:
>
> Problem here is that there won’t be any entries for any ref guide prior to
> 8.1 (at best), we’re not going to go back and re-publish them all just to add
> this. So someone asking “can I run Solr 7.7 on JDK 11” would have to look in
>
I think what I’m tending towards is mostly to fill the information vacuum we
presently have. When someone asks “can we run Solr X with Java Y”, our only
answer is “I dunno. There are all these tests we regularly run, so look through
the Lucene/Solr JIRAs and figure it out for yourself”.
I think it is appropriate to have the table in the reference guide. Yes, the
guide is versioned, but we can’t expect people to manually diff two versions to
figure out what changed.
If we expect people to upgrade to a new version, we should have the table in
the reference guide, not hidden in
Side note: Isn't wiki going away? I saw message on Commons list 4 days ago:
"Infra is decommissioning the MoinMoin wiki software that runs the wiki.a.o
system in May. That means all the content there needs to be.migrated to
new systems if it's still relevant."
Regards,
Alex
On Tue, Mar
Because the Reference Guide is versioned, we only need to discuss what JDK to
grab that works with e.g. Solr/Lucene 8. But I think your wiki page is great do
as an in-depth guide to JDKs and compatibility. Perhaps it can just live on the
wiki as now, and link to it from the RefGuide?
So on the
So I assume everyone thinks I’ve nailed it perfectly with this page?
https://wiki.apache.org/solr/SolrJavaVersions. ‘cause I haven’t seen much
feedback.
Look, we give _no_ guidance at this point about whether Lucene/Solr even work
on Java X. Well, I guess we’re saying Solr 9 works on with Java
