Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-17 Thread Jörg Schaible
Kenney Westerhof wrote: [snip] >>> The meaning of depMgt is different, applied to either local deps or >>> transitive deps, and it's not consistent. >>> >>> This somewhat describes the situation: >>> - depMgt for artifact X is used to provide defaults for direct >>> dependencies of artifact X, >>

Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Kenney Westerhof
Ralph Goers wrote: Kenney Westerhof wrote: This somewhat describes the situation: - depMgt for artifact X is used to provide defaults for direct dependencies of artifact X, and for overrides of transitive dependencies on X, unless there's also a direct dependency on X in which case the di

Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Kenney Westerhof
Jörg Schaible wrote: Kenney Westerhof wrote: Hi, Just did some test wrt MNG-2340 (using maven 2.0.7 and 2.0.6), and this is what I found: P with dependencyManagement for lucene 1.3 | + my-dep with dependency on lucene 1.4.3 + my-app with dependency on my-dep (I modified the attached projec

Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Kenney Westerhof
we need a new element, like 'transitiveDependencyManagement'. This is something I hope we won't support in 2.1... -- Kenney -Original Message----- From: Kenney Westerhof [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, June 16, 2007 7:06 AM To: Maven Developers List Subject: depM

Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Ralph Goers
Kenney Westerhof wrote: This somewhat describes the situation: - depMgt for artifact X is used to provide defaults for direct dependencies of artifact X, and for overrides of transitive dependencies on X, unless there's also a direct dependency on X in which case the direct dependency is us

Re: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Jörg Schaible
Kenney Westerhof wrote: > Hi, > > Just did some test wrt MNG-2340 (using maven 2.0.7 and 2.0.6), and this is > what I found: > > P with dependencyManagement for lucene 1.3 > | > + my-dep with dependency on lucene 1.4.3 > + my-app with dependency on my-dep > > (I modified the attached project lo

RE: depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Brian E. Fox
From: Kenney Westerhof [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, June 16, 2007 7:06 AM To: Maven Developers List Subject: depMgt (mng-1577 again) Hi, Just did some test wrt MNG-2340 (using maven 2.0.7 and 2.0.6), and this is what I found: P with dependencyManagement for lucene 1.3 | + my-dep

depMgt (mng-1577 again....)

2007-06-16 Thread Kenney Westerhof
Hi, Just did some test wrt MNG-2340 (using maven 2.0.7 and 2.0.6), and this is what I found: P with dependencyManagement for lucene 1.3 | + my-dep with dependency on lucene 1.4.3 + my-app with dependency on my-dep (I modified the attached project locally; rename my-app to my-dep and add my-ap