maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jochen Wiedmann
Hi, I just noticed that the jar plugin uses the property ${jar.forceCreation} as default of the new parameter forceCreation. I find this choice most unfortunate. Forcing creation is a very general concept: Almost any plugin could use it, including compiler, assembly, war, ear, ejb,

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Brett Porter
IMO, if something is to be general, it should be considered for the POM (like finalName). - Brett On 01/09/2006, at 6:26 PM, Jochen Wiedmann wrote: Hi, I just noticed that the jar plugin uses the property $ {jar.forceCreation} as default of the new parameter forceCreation. I find this

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jochen Wiedmann
Brett Porter wrote: IMO, if something is to be general, it should be considered for the POM (like finalName). I must admit, that I do not understand what you have in mind? Jochen - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Brett Porter
build forceCreation / Or perhaps a well known property instead/in the interim: properties forceCreation / Just a thought. On 01/09/2006, at 6:50 PM, Jochen Wiedmann wrote: Brett Porter wrote: IMO, if something is to be general, it should be considered for the POM (like finalName).

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jochen Wiedmann
Brett Porter wrote: Or perhaps a well known property instead/in the interim: properties forceCreation / The latter point is what I am asking for. In the case of the jar plugin, the property is jar.forceCreation, which I find unfortunate. Again, any chance to get this changed? I'd

RE: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Allison, Bob
- From: Jochen Wiedmann [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, September 01, 2006 06:43 To: Maven Developers List Subject: Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation Brett Porter wrote: Or perhaps a well known property instead/in the interim: properties forceCreation / The latter

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 1 Sep 06, at 4:26 AM 1 Sep 06, Jochen Wiedmann wrote: Hi, I just noticed that the jar plugin uses the property $ {jar.forceCreation} as default of the new parameter forceCreation. I find this choice most unfortunate. We talked about it on the list and there was well longer then 72

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jochen Wiedmann
On 9/1/06, Jason van Zyl [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We talked about it on the list and there was well longer then 72 hours this time. The prefix is for command line use and I asked if the new standard could be used and folks agreed. Jason, I understand completely, that it's my fault to miss

Re: maven-jar-plugin 2.1: jar.forceCreation

2006-09-01 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 1 Sep 06, at 10:17 AM 1 Sep 06, Jochen Wiedmann wrote: I do not understand where you see the problem. If all plugins that support switching off an uptodate check honour the same property (which of course they wouldn't do now, but AFAIK no plugins have implemented that yet, so it is still