Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Pedro Larroy
Regarding your paste of ldd, not sure what's your point. This is the output with the patch from PR applied, the openmp version used is the one provided by MKL: Version of the PR that removes openmp from 3rdparty comes from MKL: linux-vdso.so.1 (0x7ffc4c993000) libmkldnn.so.0

Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Pedro Larroy
Thanks for your answer Chris. I'm not militant in regards to one option or another nor belong of any club that will accept me as member, but I think we should drive this to conclusion and understand why we keep it or if we should remove it and use the platform provided version. There are open issue

Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Chris Olivier
I am curious why you're being so militant troll about this. libomp is used in every MKL build (download mxnet-mkl yourself and see). I don't see any convincing reason to change it and so far as I can tell, no real issue has been proven to be related. Anyway, I am reluctant to feed trolls any mor

Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Pedro Larroy
I had read the "Apache Voting Process" guide here: https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html and I thought code changes could be discussed on the mailing list in cases where the PR is stuck or there's no response for a long time, also I understood that -1's have to be justified. Could you, or

Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Sheng Zha
Vetos stand until and unless withdrawn by their casters [1]. The only path forward would be to convince the caster to withdraw the veto. -sz [1] https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html#Veto On 2019/06/17 17:46:59, Pedro Larroy wrote: > Thanks. > > How do we go on advancing this PR then

Re: [VOTE] Remove conflicting OpenMP from CMake builds

2019-06-17 Thread Pedro Larroy
Thanks. How do we go on advancing this PR then? all the questions have been answered, performance numbers provided and more. Until how long can a veto stand? Also without replies to contributors. Pedro. On Fri, Jun 14, 2019 at 5:44 PM Sheng Zha wrote: > > This vote is invalid as the original PR