Re: Async Lifecycle for JSF without patching JSF

2008-10-08 Thread Greg Wilkins
Matthias Wessendorf wrote: On Wed, Oct 8, 2008 at 3:06 AM, Greg Wilkins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bernd, excellent work! this is valuable feedback as there is a push by some to throw out the asynchronous proposal on the basis that it is too complex and will break frameworks. I have a

Re: Async Lifecycle for JSF without patching JSF

2008-10-08 Thread Greg Wilkins
Bernd, excellent work! this is valuable feedback as there is a push by some to throw out the asynchronous proposal on the basis that it is too complex and will break frameworks. this is valuable evidence that framework developers are able to deal with the complexities of suspend and resume.

Re: Async Lifecycle for JSF without patching JSF

2008-10-07 Thread Bernd Bohmann
Hello, I just started an Async Lifecycle module based on the suggestion from Greg Wilkins http://wiki.glassfish.java.net/Wiki.jsp?page=AlternateAsyncProposalRebuttal The module has been tested with MyFaces 1.2.4 and Sun RI 1.2_08 and the async-jsf-example-webapp from the jetty 7.0.0pre3

Re: Async Lifecycle for JSF without patching JSF

2008-10-07 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
side bash... I am not 100% how well the Servlet and JSF EGs are connected, but... wouldn't it be worth to put things like .isSuspended() on the ExternalContext = etx.isReqSuspended() ? (also, is there some async stuff on portlet?, I am only aware of of servlet, but I am generally a portlet

Re: Async Lifecycle for JSF without patching JSF

2008-10-07 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
On Wed, Oct 8, 2008 at 3:06 AM, Greg Wilkins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bernd, excellent work! this is valuable feedback as there is a push by some to throw out the asynchronous proposal on the basis that it is too complex and will break frameworks. I have a question. Since in async req.