Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-21 Thread Werner Punz
Hia, my mail was not answered so it probably went to /dev/null because it was with the same content but not as exact as the one from Ganesh regarding the id issue :-) Werner Matthias Wessendorf schrieb: Sent from my iPod. Am 21.04.2009 um 06:05 schrieb Ganesh gan...@j4fry.org: Hi

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Werner Punz
We probably have to point this out to the EG, since it is rather easy to fix this this should be fixed, after all to deal with those cases is what the name attribute in inputs exists for. It would be easy to have several viewState hidden fields one per form with formId:javax.faces.ViewState and

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Werner Punz
Hia... I sent a comment regarding this issue towards the given jcp-comments mail address. Lets see what happens. I think even if you can resolve those things on the javascript side this needs to be fixed, on the Spec side! After all the name attribute normally is there for what the spec and

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
On Mon, Apr 20, 2009 at 9:05 AM, Werner Punz werner.p...@gmail.com wrote: Hia... I sent a comment regarding this issue towards the given jcp-comments mail address. Lets see what happens. :-) /dev/null ? Another option is to have Martin (he is the ASF guy in the EG) bringing this to the EG.

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Werner Punz
Matthias Wessendorf schrieb: On Mon, Apr 20, 2009 at 9:05 AM, Werner Punz werner.p...@gmail.com wrote: Hia... I sent a comment regarding this issue towards the given jcp-comments mail address. Lets see what happens. :-) /dev/null ? That was mean :-) I will also talk to Martin about it as

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Werner Punz
Hi Alexander/Ganesh there are two parts of the spec one being the PDF the other being the JavaDocs and JSDocs, you can find the issue in the JSDocs for jsf.ajax.response specifically in the section dealing with the updates in the responseXML! here is the section: If an update element is

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Ganesh
Hi Matthias and Werner, The partial submit issue I posted to jsr-314-comme...@jcp.org received nearly instant response from Roger Kitain. Definitely not /dev/null, these guys really take their job serious. Werner, it would be great, if you forwarded your mail to the d...@myfaces list, so we

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-20 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
Sent from my iPod. Am 21.04.2009 um 06:05 schrieb Ganesh gan...@j4fry.org: Hi Matthias and Werner, The partial submit issue I posted to jsr-314-comme...@jcp.org received nearly instant response from Roger Kitain. Definitely not / dev/null, these guys really take their job serious. That

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-19 Thread Alexander Bell
Hi, in the past we did it in this way that we looking for the element only in the affected form. So in the form there is only one element with the id javax.faces.ViewState. It is also necessary that every form contains a hidden field with this id. So for JSF ok but it breaks the w3c standard and

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-18 Thread Ganesh
Hi Werner, 2 elements with the same id truely brake the HTML standard. And it's true, with Mojarra 2.0 and 2 forms on a page I get 2 identical input id=javax.faces.ViewState type=hidden value=j_id1:j_id2 name=javax.faces.ViewState/ elements! Still, I'm not able to find this in the specs, can

Re: MyFaces 2.0 Ajax - Also question to the JSF2 EG Members!

2009-04-17 Thread Werner Punz
Ok Ganesh most of the response cycle now works as expected I did not manage in time however to fix up the code for the update for a full body or head replacement to use beforeNode or afterNode to auto trigger embedded scripts! You might work that in instead of me. Another thing wich came to my