Re: JSP viewhandler: automatic id warning when using masterDetail.jsf

2007-03-30 Thread Jeff Bischoff
Mike, I get that warning message if I use a h:form with no id attribute. In fact, I see this warning on almost every page in the simple Tomahawk example app (and they don't have an id set on the form). Perhaps the warning message could be more clear? To put it another way, if I add an id to

Re: JSP viewhandler: automatic id warning when using masterDetail.jsf

2007-03-30 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Jeff, Mind opening an issue on this? I don't remember if h:form requires an id, but I don't think it is supposed to. On 3/30/07, Jeff Bischoff [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mike, I get that warning message if I use a h:form with no id attribute. In fact, I see this warning on almost every page

Re: JSP viewhandler: automatic id warning when using masterDetail.jsf

2007-03-30 Thread Jeff Bischoff
According the the Sun docs [1], it is not a required attribute. Is that official enough? (There is nothing in the spec itself about attributes of core tags, is there?) So should we remove this warning altogether, or just change it? I would be happy to open the JIRA for it, after lunch. :)

Re: JSP viewhandler: automatic id warning when using masterDetail.jsf

2007-03-30 Thread Jeff Bischoff
Upon further testing, my initial response may have been misleading. Back when I had JSP in my application, assigning explicit form ids is what got rid of this warning message. However in further testing today with the tomahawk examples from the release candidate files, I found this is no

JSP viewhandler: automatic id warning when using masterDetail.jsf

2007-03-29 Thread Mike Kienenberger
I'm not going to try to track this one down since I don't do jsp. But here's a strange warning -- UIViewRoot got assigned an automatic id in masterDetail.jsf. INFO: WARNING: Component _id0 just got an automatic id, because there was no id assigned yet. If this component was created dynamically