[Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-17 Thread Matthias Bläsing
Hi, Am Sonntag, den 17.06.2018, 14:57 -0400 schrieb Emilian Bold: > But the 'License:' header already represents a 'family'. That's why > MIT-validator should not exist in nbbuild/licenses: it's just the > plain MIT license with a particular author. beware! The file from licenses is used for the

Re: [Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-17 Thread Emilian Bold
1. The files in external/*-license.txt have everything we need. They also have the 'License:' header. I don't know why the files from nbbuild/licenses are used for the summary when we could use the files from external dependencies -license.txt. 2. MIT might be special, but nbbuild/licenses/BSD-

Re: [Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-17 Thread Tim Boudreau
> The way I see it nbbuild/licenses are 'families'. And the 'License:' > header in external/*-license.txt points to a family. A changing author line > doesn't change the license itself / the license family. > You and I are not the target audience for it - lawyers are. If that's what gets combined

Re: [Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-17 Thread Emilian Bold
There is a mix of concerns here and we are talking about different things. It's quite possible that we end up doing mistakes during our IP clearance so if a super-defensive company wants to use NetBeans they might as well decide to re-do the IP clearance themselves. If our template license file

Re: [Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-18 Thread Matthias Bläsing
Hi Emilian, Am Sonntag, den 17.06.2018, 15:24 -0400 schrieb Emilian Bold: > 1. The files in external/*-license.txt have everything we need. They > also have the 'License:' header. I don't know why the files from > nbbuild/licenses are used for the summary when we could use the files > from externa

Re: [Mentors] Re: What is nbbuild/licenses/ for? Too many files there.

2018-06-18 Thread Emilian Bold
My main point is that I assumed that nbbuild/licenses files are licenses of license *variants*. For example, if we see a variation of MIT that has one extra clause we invent some MIT-example file with the clause. So, the files is nbbuild/licenses are not about authors but about plain licenses