Re: [VOTE] release Apache OpenWebBeans-1.0.0-alpha-2

2010-08-31 Thread Jean-Louis MONTEIRO
Hi Mark, Checked out the whole project and everything works fine (compilation, tests, ...). Ran RAT plugin without any error nor warning. LICENSE, NOTICE and readme are also nice IMHO. But, i gave it a try with provided samples (binaries package). The first one, conversation-sample works fine

Re: [VOTE] release Apache OpenWebBeans-1.0.0-alpha-2

2010-08-31 Thread Mark Struberg
Hi Jean-Louis! Txs 4 the review. Guess that our ejb-phone sample isn't working since a long time now ;) This is surely something to fix, but not sure if this is a show stopper for an alpha release? The webbeans-spi.jar is currently set to 'provided'. I've now set it to compile scope and

Re: [VOTE] release Apache OpenWebBeans-1.0.0-alpha-2

2010-08-31 Thread Jean-Louis MONTEIRO
Mark, The same issue also occurs for ejb-sample and jms-sample for me. If it's not a show stopper, here is my +1. Thanks. Jean-Louis 2010/8/31 Mark Struberg strub...@yahoo.de: Hi Jean-Louis! Txs 4 the review. Guess that our ejb-phone sample isn't working since a long time now ;) This is

Re: CDI TCK Issues

2010-08-31 Thread Joseph Bergmark
I agree with you. The spec doesn't seem to provide any requirement that decorators should be injected directly into a) The injection point of the Decorated bean or b) each other. I guess I'm sure sure how you can validate a TCK test with secondary evidence and the intentions of the EG. It seems

Re: [VOTE] release Apache OpenWebBeans-1.0.0-alpha-2

2010-08-31 Thread Gurkan Erdogdu
EJB samples requires some pre-installation; one such is to provide openejb + tomcat + dependent libs like webbeans-spi So this is not stopper Gurkan From: Jean-Louis MONTEIRO jeano...@gmail.com To: dev@openwebbeans.apache.org Sent: Tue, August 31, 2010

Re: svn commit: r991165 - /openwebbeans/trunk/samples/ejb-telephone/pom.xml

2010-08-31 Thread Gurkan Erdogdu
Mark; this is not true; please rollback As I explained lots of times how to execute ejb samples. Such on user list Hello Try to use latest version, https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/openwebbeans/tags/openwebbeans-1.0.0-alpha-1/ or TRUNK. Steps to run

Re: svn commit: r991165 - /openwebbeans/trunk/samples/ejb-telephone/pom.xml

2010-08-31 Thread Mark Struberg
Hmm, I only added _1_ missing dependency, all others have been there already! So we either aim to go for a EE server WAR and set _all_ OWB jars (+ transient dependencies like javassist) to provided, or we package all into our WARs. I'd prefere the J2EE server mode! The way described below is

Re: svn commit: r991165 - /openwebbeans/trunk/samples/ejb-telephone/pom.xml

2010-08-31 Thread Gurkan Erdogdu
EJB examples are not given neither for Java EE servers or normal Jetty+Tomcat etc, those examples are specific to OPenEJB + TOmcat I described. Therefore they are different from other samples From: Mark Struberg strub...@yahoo.de To:

Re: svn commit: r991165 - /openwebbeans/trunk/samples/ejb-telephone/pom.xml

2010-08-31 Thread Mark Struberg
then we need to pack atinject and jcdi spec jars et al also! There is no 'half way'! Either we package for EE6 (which is my preferred option) or we package for a plain tomcat installation. There is no argument against introducing a profile which allows running on a naked tomcat, but since