Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-25 Thread Rodric Rabbah
Dave and I conferred and we've agreed he's in a better position today to chair the PMC. I'm happy to be in a able to learn from him in the inaugural year, assuming a successful petition to graduate. -r On Tue, Jun 25, 2019 at 5:04 PM Matt Rutkowski wrote: > > This PMC Chair nominations thread i

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-25 Thread Matt Rutkowski
This PMC Chair nominations thread is closed. Will reach out to both Dave and Rodric, as both appeared to defer to each other, to see if either wants to step back and perhaps we can reduce the need for a competitive VOTE (and have just an affirmation VOTE as this may be asked for) and move ont

Re: Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-20 Thread James Thomas
+1 on either Dave or Rodric taking the chair. Both are excellent candidates and ideally suited to the role. On Wed, 19 Jun 2019 at 20:56, David P Grove wrote: > > Rodric Rabbah wrote on 06/19/2019 06:39:19 AM: > > > > A one year rotation makes sense to me. > > Big +1 on planning for rotation. >

Re: Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-19 Thread David P Grove
Rodric Rabbah wrote on 06/19/2019 06:39:19 AM: > > A one year rotation makes sense to me. Big +1 on planning for rotation. > I’d like to nominate Dave Grove for consideration. Thanks Rodric. I'm happy to take a turn at some point. Whether that's soon or a couple years down the road doesn't ma

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-19 Thread Carlos Santana
Already expressed this privately to both Dave and Rodric they are a good candidates to be chair and to not be afraid of the responsibilities. Is more of admin on point to keep us in sync with the board and mostly make sure we don’t miss the deadlines on managerial items Carlos On Wed, Jun 19, 20

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-19 Thread Rodric Rabbah
A one year rotation makes sense to me. I’d like to nominate Dave Grove for consideration. Dave is engaged on the general list, and I’ve consulted him many times on the Apache Way and for pointers to Apache docs. He’s also lead several releases and followed up on issues noted during voting to t

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-19 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
On Wed, Jun 19, 2019 at 11:48 AM Justin Mclean wrote: > ...Just a reminder, the chair is not a leadership role, but it it more a > secretarial and admin role... I was going to say that! In extreme cases the chair might have to make decisions on behalf of the PMC but in 19 years at Apache I don'

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-19 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Just a reminder, the chair is not a leadership role, but it it more a secretarial and admin role in that they report to board on how the project is going and make sure the projects rosters are kept up to date. Setting direction for the project is not part of that role, see [1] Thanks, Just

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Rodric Rabbah
Thanks Dominic for the kind words. I'm humbled. It's been wonderful seeing several committers emerge to also lead this project and contribute in various ways. It would be amazing to see others also considered as a testament to the maturity of the project. -r On Tue, Jun 18, 2019 at 9:47 PM Domi

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Dominic Kim
Aside from the duties of the Char, IMHO, a PMC Chair should be the one who loves the project and makes devotion to the project the most. Also, he should keep eyes on most of the works around the project and try to get more people involved in the project. He should lead the project in the right dire

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Matt Sicker
I'll note as a PMC Chair of another project here, it's not a heavy burden at all, especially if you're already reading the mailing lists and participating in release votes. Please be encouraged to volunteer to chair the PMC! On Tue, 18 Jun 2019 at 12:15, Rodric Rabbah wrote: > > This link http://

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Rodric Rabbah
This link http://www.apache.org/dev/pmc.html#chair is helpful to understand the duties of the PMC chair. -r

Re: [ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Matt Rutkowski
PS Please know that I do not intend to make any nominations (self or otherwise). Kind regards, Matt

[ACTION REQUIRED] Nominations for PMC Chair for TLP graduation resolution

2019-06-18 Thread Matt Rutkowski
As part of the graduation process as a top-level project, we must craft a draft resolution which includes the naming of a PMC Chair for the project. Please see discussion and actual draft using these links: * dev list:https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/resumedraft.action?draftId=1155269