Sure, makes sense. I’ve opened a separate PR for it and will tag the issue to
it!
-Adnan
> On Sep 19, 2025, at 3:15 PM, Michael Collado wrote:
>
> Agree - changes to the status codes should accompany a major version bump.
> Maybe log this as an issue and add to a 2.0.0 milestone release?
>
>
Agree - changes to the status codes should accompany a major version bump.
Maybe log this as an issue and add to a 2.0.0 milestone release?
On Thu, Sep 18, 2025 at 4:08 PM Adnan Hemani
wrote:
> Hi Dmitri,
>
> The change of the response code from 201 to 204 were discussed in Yufei’s
> response wi
Hi Dmitri,
The change of the response code from 201 to 204 were discussed in Yufei’s
response within this email chain (and my response to his email as well).
I can understand this being considered a “major change” requiring a major
version increment. In the interest of time, I can remove that
Hi Adnan,
Changes to response bodies LGTM.
However, PR [2603] that references this discussion thread, also changes one
of the response codes from 201 to 204 (which was not yet discussed in this
thread, if I'm not mistaken).
The response code change appears to be meaningful, however, I believe it
Hi all,
Thanks for the responses - and sorry for the delay, the past few weeks have
been quite busy.
I agree with all the points presented.
* I will start a vote soon for the following endpoints, once I have a draft PR
that shows the proposed changes: createCatalog, createPrincipalRole,
creat
Thanks for the proposal, Adnan.
Returning representations from the create endpoints makes sense to me and
will reduce a follow-up GET in most clients.
For addGrantToCatalogRole, the grant itself is more a relationship between
entities than entity itself. I understand it returns 201(Created) now,
Hi Adnan,
Thanks for bringing this topic to our attention.
In general, for operations creating new resources, the event
instrumentation logic could rely on the incoming request. E.g. for
createCatalog, if the response does not contain the catalog resource,
it is generally OK to grab it from the i
