Hi Joe,
I will improve the PIP, and then send it back to the email thread soon.
-Penghui
在 2020年2月25日 +0800 AM4:41，Sijie Guo ，写道：
> On Mon, Feb 24, 2020 at 11:33 AM Joe F wrote:
>
> > Sjiie, Penghui,
> >
> > Thank you. Can we get the PIP to be a more detailed write-up ? I would
> > like this PIP
On Mon, Feb 24, 2020 at 11:33 AM Joe F wrote:
> Sjiie, Penghui,
>
> Thank you. Can we get the PIP to be a more detailed write-up ? I would
> like this PIP to be more comprehensive
>
I think Penghui can work on improving this to make this PIP to be more
comprehensive.
It is good to start with
Sjiie, Penghui,
Thank you. Can we get the PIP to be a more detailed write-up ? I would
like this PIP to be more comprehensive
>>Hence we need to draw an agreement on understanding
>>WHAT is actually guarantees the correctness in current Pulsar design. We
>>then can move forward with a conclusio
Sorry for the late reply.
Joe - There are two things I would like to clarify first.
1) I think you have a misunderstanding about the zookeeper lock "ephemeral
znode" and bookkeeper/ML fencing. Let's step back to understand the current
Pulsar's behavior first.
- A zookeeper lock doesn't prevent a
On Sat, Feb 22, 2020 at 6:28 PM PengHui Li wrote:
> Hi, joe
>
> The fundamental correctness is guaranteed by the fencing mechanism
> provided by Apache BookKeeper and the CAS operation provided by the
> metadata storage. Both fencing and CAS operations will prevent two owners
> updating data or m
Hi, joe
The fundamental correctness is guaranteed by the fencing mechanism provided by
Apache BookKeeper and the CAS operation provided by the metadata storage. Both
fencing and CAS operations will prevent two owners updating data or metadata at
the same time. This default shutdown behavior isn
My concerns are listed in the PR comments.
A broker is allowed to operate on a (resource) bundle under a lock. When a
broker loses its session, the lock ownership COULD be lost. The right thing
at this point is to give up the resource and re-acquire it. ( In fact,
shutdown is just a shortcut to do
Hi all,
I have drafted a proposal for improving broker's Zookeeper session timeout
handling. You can find at
https://github.com/apache/pulsar/wiki/PIP-57%3A-Improve-Broker%27s-Zookeeper-Session-Timeout-Handling
Also I copy it to the email thread for easier to view. Any suggestions or ideas
wel
