Hi Michael,
I appreciate your detailed explanation.
I agree with your proposal.
It seems that sharing version information between the proxy
and broker would indeed be beneficial for debugging purposes without
creating
an unnecessary tight coupling between the two components.
I appreciate your wi
Thanks for your feedback Mattison and Xiangying. I'll note that the
PIP vote did close already and I have the implementation just about
done, but I'm happy to discuss this feature a bit more here.
> we should avoid coupling the concepts in the proxy and the broker
Sharing version information does
Dear Michael,
I think the intention behind this is excellent, but directly modifying the
protocol might be a bit too heavy-handed.
This approach may lead to data redundancy.
In large-scale clusters, every client connection would need to transmit
the extra proxy version information,
which might i
Sorry for the late response.
Why do we need to make the broker aware of the proxy when, by normal software
design, we should avoid coupling the concepts in the proxy and the broker? The
previous authentication was for historical reasons, but we should not continue
to introduce this coupling.
T
Great suggestions, Enrico.
> It would be interesting to reject connections on the Proxy if the
> client tries to set that field.
I support making the proxy reject invalid input. We could also have
the client reject connections where the client connect command
includes `original_principal`, `origi
Makes sense.
It would be interesting to reject connections on the Proxy if the
client tries to set that field.
On the broker there is no way to distinguish a proxy from a client, that's fair.
But on the proxy it is not expected to see a connection from another proxy.
+1
Enrico
Il giorno ven 24
Hi, Michael
Thanks for initiating this PIP.
+1
BR,
Zike Yang
Zike Yang
On Fri, Feb 24, 2023 at 12:16 PM Michael Marshall wrote:
>
> Hi Pulsar Community,
>
> In talking with Zike Yang on
> https://github.com/apache/pulsar/pull/19540, we identified that it
> would be helpful for the proxy to f
Hi Pulsar Community,
In talking with Zike Yang on
https://github.com/apache/pulsar/pull/19540, we identified that it
would be helpful for the proxy to forward its own version when
connecting to the broker. Here is a related PIP to improve the
connection information available to operators.
Issue:
