Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Julian Hyde
Thanks for your answer, Frank. I thought I'd ask just in case the project had gotten stuck in a place not needed by current requirements. Let's definitely continue the discussion after the release. All of the components that are part of a project should be released from time to time, and, I dare

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Frank Greguska
I'll do my best. Technically, SDAP has 10 repositories: https://github.com/apache?utf8=%E2%9C%93=incubator-sdap== A few of those should be archived/cleaned up at this point but that hasn't been a priority. In general though, SDAP is not one piece of software. It is a suite of software needed to

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Julian Hyde
Can someone explain why SDAP has 3 separate GitHub repositories rather than one? It's not my place to suggest changes. But if the separate repositories are causing more pain than joy, it might be worth reconsidering. (Several times I have typed in https://github.com/apache/incubator-sdap/ and

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Riley Kuttruff
Thanks. This change will require an update to the build instructions. I have an open pull request to get that done [1] that I would like to get approved and merged before trying the next rc. [1] https://github.com/apache/incubator-sdap-nexus/pull/225 On 2023/01/03 21:50:30 Frank Greguska

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Frank Greguska
Makes sense to me. - Frank On Tue, Jan 3, 2023 at 1:16 PM Riley Kuttruff wrote: > I've been looking into better structuring our release artifacts and was > wondering if anyone had any opinions on how I've updated it: > > > > (sdap-nexus) rileykk@MT-110978 apache-sdap-1.0.0-rc3 % tar -tf >

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Riley Kuttruff
I've been looking into better structuring our release artifacts and was wondering if anyone had any opinions on how I've updated it: > (sdap-nexus) rileykk@MT-110978 apache-sdap-1.0.0-rc3 % tar -tf > apache-sdap-nexusproto-1.0.0-src-incubating.tar.gz >

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Riley Kuttruff
I see. I'm pretty sure we may need to put out a new release candidate. At the very least we need to update the copyright and also switch to DISCLAIMER-WIP On 2023/01/03 18:55:52 Frank Greguska wrote: > My thoughts: > > gradle-wrapper.jar and gradlew.bat can be removed from the actual release >

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Frank Greguska
My thoughts: gradle-wrapper.jar and gradlew.bat can be removed from the actual release artifacts. I agree the project organization is a bit awkward, but I don't think we can/should address that right now. We have to update the copyright The climatology directory all came from Brian Wilson. I

Re: [DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-03 Thread Riley Kuttruff
Another issue that was pointed out is the climatology directory containing improperly(?) licensed code [1]. Are we using anything in there? Should it be excluded from releases? [1] https://lists.apache.org/thread/brr31mjz13xrgwf6h6fdnnl30tvr4hzy On 2023/01/03 02:36:14 Riley Kuttruff wrote: >

[DISCUSS] RC2 IPMC vote thread

2023-01-02 Thread Riley Kuttruff
Hello everyone, The IPMC vote has turned up a couple issues with our release: - The presence of a precompiled jar (gradle-wrapper.jar) in the nexusproto release [1] - Our project organization is 'awkward' and 'cumbersome' [2] - The copyright line in our NOTICE files is now out of date