[slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2005-12-20 Thread Boris Unckel
Hello, this thread started at the user's list, but Ceki asked to answer on the delevopers list for points regarding the implementation: Ceki Gülcü wrote: > A quick look at org.x4juli.X4JuliLogger and > org.slf4j.impl.X4JuliLoggerFactory indicates that you have done a very > good job. It is not ex

Re: [slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2005-12-22 Thread Ceki Gülcü
Comments inline. At 10:26 PM 12/20/2005, Boris Unckel wrote: [snip] I think one of the most important design decisions (espescially in open source) is freedom of choice within a custom (propietary) implementation. A wrapper should (as slf4j does) be an interface so people can implement it as t

Re: [slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2005-12-23 Thread Boris Unckel
Good Morning, > To address this problem, you could split x4juli to x4juli.jar and > slf4j-x4juli.jar (with the former depending on the latter). In this > setting, slf4j-x4juli.jar would contain slf4j classes (o.s.Logger, > o.s.ILoggerFactory, etc.) plus o.s.impl.StaticLoggerBinderbound to > o.

Re: [slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2006-01-03 Thread Ceki Gülcü
At 10:35 AM 12/23/2005, Boris Unckel wrote: Good Morning, > To address this problem, you could split x4juli to x4juli.jar and > slf4j-x4juli.jar (with the former depending on the latter). In this > setting, slf4j-x4juli.jar would contain slf4j classes (o.s.Logger, > o.s.ILoggerFactory, etc.) plu

Re: [slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2006-01-05 Thread Boris Unckel
Hello, Ceki Gülcü wrote: >> There may be another solution: The only difference betwen the default >> JDK14LoggerFactory and X4JuliLoggerFactory is that X4JuliLoggerFactory >> has a >> compile-time dependendy to x4juli and detects wheter to use native >> interface >> or the normal wrapper class app

Re: [slf4j-dev] x4juli and slf4j

2006-01-09 Thread Ceki Gülcü
At 10:17 PM 1/5/2006, Boris Unckel wrote: I hope to release x4juli 0.7 soon. Can you estimate a timeframe when the next slf4j version will arrive? Can you give me a hint whether you accept the patch in Bugzilla #10 or not? Although a benign refactorization, I tend to decline the patch for th