Re: Should v2 API be "experimental"

2021-10-27 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
Wed, 27 Oct 2021 at 12:04, Ishan Chattopadhyaya wrote: > > Alex, these seem to be issues with config API (and should be solved), while > this discussion is about v2 version of all APIs. What is the relevance here? > > On Wed, 27 Oct, 2021, 9:24 pm Alexandre Rafalovitch, > wrote:

Re: Should v2 API be "experimental"

2021-10-27 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
I feel that the summary of my umbrella case (SOLR-14795) qualifies for this: " General issues with output being materialized schema: * parameters have already been resolved and are not indicated * empty keys may not be output (e.g. dataDir) * default parameters will be output that are not in solrc

Re: Should v2 API be "experimental"

2021-10-26 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
I felt that V2's lack of support for defaults was a serious architectural issue that is hard to just close eyes on. Regards, Alex On Tue., Oct. 26, 2021, 3:17 p.m. Eric Pugh, < ep...@opensourceconnections.com> wrote: > I’d very much like to see this as well. > > I’ve been thinking that I woul

Re: Solr 9.0 release blockers

2021-10-25 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
I did some analysis work on that a while ago, though now I realized I did not mark it well with V2 perhaps. https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-14795 Regards, Alex. On Mon, 25 Oct 2021 at 16:12, Jason Gerlowski wrote: > > > Is there an umbrella Jira with open subtasks for every Api th

Re: Solr and Jetty and Servlets

2021-08-19 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
> But a little more effort on those json files that make up V2 I looked into that and during the in-depth testing realised that V2 did not support default values (it writes out current values only), nor did it have a proper round-trip story, especially for the nested configurations. So, it was - ar

Re: Does Solr try to read stored fields for every search request?

2021-06-03 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
These may be interesting and relevant: * https://solr.apache.org/guide/8_8/query-settings-in-solrconfig.html#enablelazyfieldloading * https://solr.apache.org/guide/8_8/defining-fields.html#optional-field-type-override-properties (last entry "large") Regards, Alex. On Thu, 3 Jun 2021 at 10:32

Re: [DISCUSS] Make Cloud mode the default option in bin/solr

2021-05-23 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
The worry I have is that this (and previous cloud-first) move pushes Solr - even further - into Innovator's Dilemma situation. It is a complicated and nuanced worry, so I would understand if nobody else shares it. But I felt it was still worth mentioning. The core issue is that even though Solr is

Re: Post Tool

2021-04-28 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
"Good enough/Recommended" for what? Serious question. Because it may be - more than - good enough to "send files to the server", but the post tool is also doing a lot of Solr business logic that beginner users may not have understood yet. Like automatic commit. Like choosing endpoint and content t

Re: Solr Roadmap (and 9.0 release planning)

2021-04-28 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
On v2 API, I did some review a while ago, though the goal was to compare its coverage with solrconfig.xml, rather than with V1. My discoveries (umbrella and children) are in SOLR-14795 . Regards, Alex. On Wed, 28 Apr 2021 at 12:04, Jan Høydahl wrote: > > Hi all, > > We've come a long way si

Re: Welcome Eric Pugh to the Apache Solr PMC

2021-04-24 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
Congratulations Eric, Regards, Alex. On Sat, 24 Apr 2021 at 07:14, Eric Pugh wrote: > > Thank you all! I’m excited about the future of Solr, and it’s potential to > solve new use cases in search. > > On Apr 23, 2021, at 8:19 PM, Jan Høydahl wrote: > > I am pleased to announce that Eric Pu

Re: Removing books from frontpage of solr.apache.org

2021-03-24 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
+1 In terms of visibility, I think we should promote the Reference Guide on the home page more heavily. Even if it were some sort of partial TOC screenshot. Regards, Alex. On Wed, 24 Mar 2021 at 04:38, Jan Høydahl wrote: > Hi, > > I'm proposing to remove the books section from the frontpage

Summary and discussion request for Solr 9 blocker issue SOLR-14701 (schemaless mode)

2021-03-20 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
Hello, I was asked to draw attention and summarize the cross-road situation with the current Solr 9 blocker issue about the "schemaless mode". Basically, the current shameless mode is broken in two main ways, one familiar and one that is a bit more obscure: 1) Familiar: The schemaless mode will u

Re: Disable autocomplete for solr console login

2021-03-10 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
This seems two different things here, based on the fact that you already have a proposed solution: 1) You want a fix for the Solr you are running already? This may not be an ideal solution, but if you fix the login.html in the server/solr-webapp/webapp/partials, does it address your problem? 2) As