Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-29 Thread Dave
Well no one in their right mind is going to go to any solr version .0 unless you really just want to ruin your month and life waiting for version.5. Every single base solr release has a bunch of problems that get solved and I’m sure the true fields will come back as they have no overhead and c

Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-27 Thread David Eric Pugh
Hoss, I had a conversation with David (on the phone) about just that idea, of moving some things to solr-sandbox, so I am definitely receptive to it. TrieField is a good example of one who is maybe okay just "hiding" in the source tree.    One issue with moving it to sandbox is that we don't rea

Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-26 Thread Chris Hostetter
: I'd prefer to see Trie fields hang out a bit longer. These fields are : proper plugins (i.e. they subclass types), so their presence is relatively : minor for their project maintenance impact. Hrm, sort of? 1) There is a lot cruft sprinkled through out the codebase for dealing with TrieFiel

Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-26 Thread David Smiley
I'd prefer to see Trie fields hang out a bit longer. These fields are proper plugins (i.e. they subclass types), so their presence is relatively minor for their project maintenance impact. On Fri, Sep 26, 2025 at 12:10 AM Rahul Goswami wrote: > Personally, I would really prefer the Trie fields

Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-25 Thread Rahul Goswami
Personally, I would really prefer the Trie fields not be removed entirely. It allows me to reindex in-place without service disruption and without needing additional hardware (even temporarily) since I can continue with the same schema. Maybe we can leave these as is if they don't contribute to an

Re: Deprecated Code that can be removed in Solr 10

2025-09-25 Thread Chris Hostetter
: With 10 starting to loom, me and Claude went and looked for code that could be removed.   Here is what we found: : https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SOLR/Solr+10+Deprecation+Removal+Opportunities You two are my newest favorite people. : I was thinking of teeing up a single JIRA with