Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Lukasz Lenart
2012/11/20 ChadDavis : > I tried to migrate our project, a struts 2 project, to Java7 and hit > surprising amounts of incompatibility with our open source dependencies. > For instance, our OSG dependencies were broken because they can't compile > under java7 due to their use of a javac flag, gone

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Christian Grobmeier
1.6 is fine if you increase the major number of the version (it might break some things). Not sure if 2.4 is enough or if it needs to be 3.0 That said, for me personally 1.6 is fine and I do not miss 1.5 support Cheers On Tue, Nov 20, 2012 at 3:18 PM, Lukasz Lenart wrote: > Hi, > > Support for J

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread ChadDavis
I tried to migrate our project, a struts 2 project, to Java7 and hit surprising amounts of incompatibility with our open source dependencies. For instance, our OSG dependencies were broken because they can't compile under java7 due to their use of a javac flag, gone under java7, that allows 1.4 c

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Dave Newton
We definitely can't make 1.7 a requirement. I know plenty of places still running 1.5 or 1.6. Such is Java. What does dropping 1.5 support actually mean? Using @Override on interface methods? What else? Dave On Tue, Nov 20, 2012 at 9:44 AM, Rene Gielen wrote: > In a perfect world, I'd require 1

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Rene Gielen
In a perfect world, I'd require 1.7 as well. To be more realistic on what we'd expect typical Struts 2.5+ to run on, I fear 1.6 will be a supported and required platform for at least 2-3 years from now on, especially regarding the fact that 1.6 is not deprecated as long as you are willing to pay fo

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Rene Gielen
Dropping Java 1.5 seems reasonable for the 2.5 (aka 3.0) branch which is intended to introduce breaking changes. I'm not in favor to do this for any version < 2.5 René Lukasz Lenart schrieb: >Hi, > >Support for Java 1.6 will end soon and I think we should also drop >support for Java 1.5 in

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Umesh Awasthi
+1 for moving beyond 1.5 Though 1.6 is still widely in use but for 1.5 its only if there is no other options Thanks Umesh On Tue, Nov 20, 2012 at 7:48 PM, Lukasz Lenart wrote: > Hi, > > Support for Java 1.6 will end soon and I think we should also drop > support for Java 1.5 in Struts 2. During

Re: Drop support for Java 1.5

2012-11-20 Thread Paul Benedict
Keep what you have in Struts 2. Struts 3 should require 1.7 On Tue, Nov 20, 2012 at 8:18 AM, Lukasz Lenart wrote: > Hi, > > Support for Java 1.6 will end soon and I think we should also drop > support for Java 1.5 in Struts 2. During one of the Devoxx talk there > was a question about how many of