Re: [DISCUSSION] Deprecation of YuniKorn plugin deployment mode

2024-04-10 Thread Craig Condit
> On Apr 9, 2024, at 9:48 PM, Weiwei Yang wrote: > > My concern is from another angle, though the plugin mode is not as > elegant as the standalone mode, it works and serves the purpose of > bringing yunikorn values without breaking existing things. Except that the plugin mode does “break

Re: [DISCUSSION] Deprecation of YuniKorn plugin deployment mode

2024-04-09 Thread Weiwei Yang
Hi Craig Thanks for the write-up and it clearly explains the rationale behind this. I appreciate you listing all these things in detail to help all community members understand in depth about the issue. Thank you! I agree with all the points you listed. My concern is from another angle, though

Re: [DISCUSSION] Deprecation of YuniKorn plugin deployment mode

2024-04-09 Thread Peter Bacsko
Hi all, thanks Craig for writing this excellent, detailed summary, including historical context. As we already talked about it on Slack, I'm definitely +1 for removing the plugin. My main gripes are: 1. It overcomplicates the codebase. Two branches for plugin vs non-plugin mode, scheduler cache

[DISCUSSION] Deprecation of YuniKorn plugin deployment mode

2024-04-09 Thread Craig Condit
--- Preface === There have been quite a few informal discussions on this topic, and it's time that we bring this formally to the yunikorn-dev mailing list for further discussion... --- Summary === We are actively planning to deprecate the YuniKorn plugin mode for eventual